‘You're Not a Man at All!’: Masculinity, Responsibility, and Staying on the Land in Contemporary Ireland

Abstract

This paper explores some of the competing pressures at work in the lives of a particular group of Irish men, that is, young male farmers working in different types of farming regions in Ireland. As the economic and social landscape of farming is undergoing transformation, reducing the attractiveness and viability of farming as an occupation, there is, simultaneously, a strong association between constructions of farming masculinity and staying on the land. The paper explores some of these tensions. Farming masculinities are bound up with a sense of cultural and familial responsibility, which is attached to maintaining the family farm, but it is increasingly difficult to fulfil these responsibilities in the current environment. This can lead to stress and anxiety on the part of young farmers. It is argued that the construction and negotiation of farming masculinity is spatially contingent, reflecting local and regional geographies of gender.

She leaves, he stays? Sex-selective migration in rural East Germany

“…Young women are more education-minded and tend to reach higher educational levels than the male rural youth. This growing gender divide is rooted in a strong association between femininity and education on the one hand and masculinity and physical work on the other (Ní Laoire, 2005). Corbett (2009: 1) argues that "formal education is designed for those who leave", i.e.…”

Does climatic crisis in Australia’s food bowl create a basis for change in agricultural gender relations?

“…The traditional family farming discourse, and its supportive gender ideology, has several potential outcomes for menit locks them into remaining on unviable farms, it reinforces their attachment to land and place, it prioritizes men's historical positioning as ''farmer,'' and it reinforces a dominant masculine position (Connell and Messerschmidt 2006;Dempsey 1992;Ní Laoire 2005) that downplays the efforts of women. What comes through from men is their intense distress at their failure to recreate the historically significant position of ''farmer'' and to continue traditional gender relations.…”

“…Many farm men are reflecting on their previously secure position as farmers and breadwinners, custodians, and providers (Ní Laoire 2005), and many women on their workloads and lifestyle.…”

The Presentation of Masculinity in Everyday Life: Contextual Variations in the Masculine Behaviour of Young Irish Men

“…Recently, there has been a burgeoning of interest in the topic of Irish masculinity (see, for example, the 2005 special issue on masculinity in the Irish Journal of Sociology) that has been generated by the shifting social and economic circumstances that have accompanied Ireland's belated industrialization (Ferguson 2001a;Ni Laoire 2005). Ferguson argues that a primary promoter of changes in Irish masculinity has been the increase in individualism that co-occurs with economic development and the decline of traditional institutional powers.…”