Young Children and Voice Search: What We Know From Human-Computer Interaction Research

Abstract

Young children are prolific question-askers. The growing ubiquity of voice interfaces (e.g., Apple’s Siri, Amazon’s Alexa), as well as the availability of voice input in search fields, now make it possible for children to ask questions via Internet search when they are able to speak clearly, but before they have learned to read and write, typically between 3 and 6 years of age. The prevalence of voice search makes it important to understand children’s changing conceptions of digital devices as a source of information and the role of technology-mediated question-asking in development. While limited research has focused on young children’s use of voice interfaces, reviewing two related bodies of literature sheds light on how this use might unfold. This paper brings together studies of how children look for information, and of how they perceive and understand the informational and social roles of technology, drawing on human-computer interaction research. We conclude by highlighting lines of questioning for future work on younger children’s interaction through voice search.

Understanding how African‐American and Latinx youth evaluate their experiences with digital assistants

“…Our finding about the challenges that children face when using digital assistants resonates with Druga, Williams, Breazeal, and Resnick (2017) that children tried to increase their voice level or pause in their questions. Our findings also confirmed results from Lovato and Piper's (2019) findings that young children felt confused by their lack of a full understanding of what the system can and cannot answer.…”

Alexa, she's not human but… Unveiling the drivers of consumers' trust in voice‐based artificial intelligence

“…This is interesting as it is counter to previous literature yet can be explained by the fact that social presence is fully developed when understanding and immediacy are present (Mackey & Freyberg, 2010). As such, due to the relative infancy of VA technology, some may not be as responsive as others in showing confusion with accents, misunderstanding keywords, or providing irrelevant information (Lovato & Piper, 2019). Accordingly, the illusion of dealing with a “human” is broken in these circumstances, which can lead to a lack of faith in the VAs abilities.…”

“…As such, due to the relative infancy of VA technology, some may not be as responsive as others in showing confusion with accents, misunderstanding keywords, or providing irrelevant information (Lovato & Piper, 2019). Accordingly, the illusion of dealing with a "human" is broken in these circumstances, which can lead to a lack of faith in the VAs abilities.…”

Constructivist Dialogue Mapping Analysis of Ant Adaptation

“…According to a report by RideOut Media (2017) Most American Children (98%) are now in a home with a tablet or smartphone. These provide ubiquitous access to microphone, voice search enabled devices (Lovato & Piper, 2019). Otter.ai, an AI powered transcription service, along with REV.com, are dropping the cost and increasing the accuracy of automated transcription.…”