Metallation of (2-CH2RC6H4)2, with excess Li(tmen) Bun (tmen = NNN'N'-tetramethylethylenediamine) yields the crystalline compounds [{Li(tmen)}2{(2-CHRC6H4)2}] [R = H (7) or SiMe, (9)] whereas for 2-methyl-2'-trimethylsilylmethylbiphenyl, although selectivity is maintained, the crystalline product is a monolithiated species. This difference has been rationalised on the basis of the results of the crystal structure determination of the lithium complexes ( 7) and ( 9). The structure of ( 7) is polymeric (cf. dimeric in benzene by ebullioscopy) with a ' metallacycle ' lithium and a lithium bridging methylene groups of different ' metallacycles ' (electron-deficient bonding) : Li-C (mean) 2.30 A ; Li-C-Li (mean) 159.5, C-Li-C (mean) 106.5". Compound (9) is best described as a ' contact ion-pair ' structure; Li-C(H)SiMe3 contacts, 2.22(1) and 2.1 9(2) A. Lithiation of 2-[bis(trimethylsilyl)methyl]-2'-methylbiphenyl results in the formation of (9), via an anionic 1,6-silyl migration.