Hydrogenated soybean oil can be used to spare fish oil in aquafeeds, but lipid digestibility may be a limiting factor. We evaluated the performance and tissue fatty acid composition of juvenile Yellowtail Seriola dorsalis that were fed diets containing menhaden fish oil (positive control), hydrogenated soybean oil (negative control), or hydrogenated soybean oil amended with 1% mixed bile acids, casein, whey protein, or monoglycerides as emulsifying agents. Juvenile fish (~10 g) were stocked in a semi-closed recirculation aquaculture system (15 fish/tank), diets were randomly assigned to tanks in triplicate (N = 3), and fish were fed in slight excess of estimated apparent satiation amounts for 6 h/d with belt feeders. After 8 weeks, production performance was equivalent for fish fed the positive control and negative control feeds; amending the hydrogenated soybean oil-based feeds with casein, whey protein, or monoglycerides did not affect performance, whereas adding mixed bile acids significantly impaired performance (weight gain = 655-681% versus 459%; survival = 98-100% versus 49%; feed conversion ratio = 1.19-1.22 versus 1.56). Whole-body fatty acid composition tended to mirror dietary composition except that fish receiving the hydrogenated soybean oil-based feeds exhibited disproportionately lower levels of saturated fatty acids and higher levels of monounsaturated fatty acids, long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids, and n-3 and n-6 fatty acids compared to dietary levels. Results suggest that casein, whey protein, and monoglycerides could be added to saturated fatty acid-rich hydrogenated soybean oil-based diets to reduce tissue fatty acid profile distortion, but production performance might not be enhanced. Of all the hydrogenated soybean oil-based feeds in this study, the one supplemented with casein resulted in a whole-body fatty acid profile closest to that of fish fed the fish oil-based feed. Mixed bile acids should not be added due to the resulting negative impacts on survival and growth.
Feeds for carnivorous fish like Largemouth Bass Micropterus salmoides are commonly based on marine‐origin fish meal, but this ingredient is costly. Fish meal derived from undesirable species, such as invasive Asian carp Hypophthalmichthys spp., is a promising alternative source of protein for carnivorous fish, but information regarding its biological value as a feed ingredient is limited. Accordingly, we evaluated the growth performance of juvenile Largemouth Bass (initial weight, 11.6±0.2 g [mean±SE]) reared for 8 weeks on practical diets (∼14.5% lipid, ∼42% digestible protein) containing different levels of menhaden fish meal (MFM), Asian carp meal (CFM), or a 50:50 blend of these ingredients such that 40% (40 MFM, 40 CFM) or 60% (60 MFM, 60 CFM, 60 Blend) of the estimated digestible protein content was derived from fish meal. Weight gain (329–388%), feed conversion ratio (0.78–0.97), and specific growth rate (2.65–2.88% body weight/d) were generally consistent among treatments. Although our results suggest that performance is greater among fish fed diets with greater fish meal inclusion, regardless of its origin, this trend was not supported by clear statistical evidence. Asian carp fish meal appears to be broadly equivalent to MFM in feeds for Largemouth Bass. Development of CFM as a feed ingredient may offer producers of Largemouth Bass and other carnivorous fishes some savings in feed cost and encourage the harvest of invasive Asian carp.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.