Animated pedagogical agents (APAs) have the potential to provide one-on-one, justin-time instruction, guidance or mentoring in classrooms where such individualized human interactions may be infeasible. Much current APA research focuses on a wide range of design variables tested with small samples or in laboratory settings, while overlooking important practical issues relating to large-scale, school-based implementations. The present study provides an early step in addressing this gap by investigating the patterns, affordances and challenges of sustained classroom use of APAs. During a 15-class-period science curriculum, middle school students in the treatment groups (n Dr C-1 = 191; nDr C-2 = 181) had uninterrupted classroom access to one of the two APAs, while control group students (n = 149) completed the same curriculum without APA access. Usage patterns indicate that students accessed the APAs on a fluctuating, "as needed," basis corresponding to the introductory, information-gathering, and synthesis and reporting segments of the curriculum. Survey results revealed no statistically significant difference in student feelings toward the APAs between the two treatments. While treatment students reported that the APAs were unique, reliable, timely resources, interviews indicate little difference between their experiences with the curriculum and those of the control group. Results presented here provide guidance for researchers and practitioners.
Practitioner NotesWhat is already known about this topic • Student-scientist partnerships can enhance participant content learning and gains related to motivation and self-efficacy in science but are difficult to scale up. • Science inquiry programs accommodate much greater numbers of students but provide limited to no access to scientist mentors. • The technology behind animated pedagogical agents (APAs) suggests the potential to provide large-scale, inexhaustible access to "virtual" scientist mentors. • Research to date has tended to overlook important practical issues (such as cost, reliability, bandwidth requirements and accessibility) relating to large-scale, schoolbased implementations.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.