Background Non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) is over three times as common in men as it is in women; however, female patients do not respond as well to immunotherapeutic treatments and experience worse clinical outcomes than their male counterparts. Based on the established sexual dimorphism in mucosal immune responses, we hypothesized that the tumor immune microenvironment of bladder cancer differs between the sexes, and this may contribute to discrepancies in clinical outcomes. Objective To determine biological sex-associated differences in the expression of immune regulatory genes and spatial organization of immune cells in tumors from NMIBC patients. Design, setting, and participants Immune regulatory gene expression levels in tumors from male ( n = 357) and female ( n = 103) patients were measured using whole transcriptome profiles of tumors from the UROMOL cohort. Multiplexe immunofluorescence was performed to evaluate the density and spatial distribution of immune cells and immune checkpoints in tumors from an independent cohort of patients with NMIBC ( n = 259 males and n = 73 females). Outcome measurements and statistical analysis Transcriptome sequencing data were analyzed using DESeq2 in R v4.0.1, followed by application of the Kruskal-Wallis test to determine gene expression differences between tumors from males and females. Immunofluorescence data analyses were conducted using R version 3.5.3. Survival analysis was performed using survminer packages. Results and limitations High-grade tumors from female patients exhibited significantly increased expression of B-cell recruitment ( CXCL13 ) and function ( CD40 )-associated genes and the immune checkpoint genes CTLA4 , PDCD1 , LAG3 , and ICOS . Tumors from female patients showed significantly higher infiltration of PD-L1+ cells and CD163+ M2-like macrophages than tumors from male patients. Increased abundance of CD163+ macrophages and CD79a+ B cells were associated with decreased recurrence-free survival. Conclusions These novel findings highlight the necessity of considering sexual dimorphism in the design of future immunotherapy trials in NMIBC. Patient summary In this study, we measured the abundance of various immune cell types between tumors from male and female patients with non–muscle-invasive bladder cancer. We demonstrate that tumors from female patients have a significantly higher abundance of immunosuppressive macrophages that express CD163. Higher abundance of tumor-associated CD163-expressing macrophages and B cells is associated with shorter recurrence-free survival in both male a...

Intrinsic molecular subtypes may explain marked variation between bladder cancer patients in prognosis and response to therapy. Complex testing algorithms and little attention to more prevalent, early-stage (non-muscle invasive) bladder cancers (NMIBCs) have hindered implementation of subtyping in clinical practice. Here, using a three-antibody immunohistochemistry (IHC) algorithm, we identify the diagnostic and prognostic associations of well-validated proteomic features of basal and luminal subtypes in NMIBC. By IHC, we divided 481 NMIBCs into basal (GATA3 À /KRT5 + ) and luminal (GATA3 + /KRT5 variable) subtypes. We further divided the luminal subtype into URO (p16 low), URO-KRT5 + (KRT5 + ), and genomically unstable (GU) (p16 high) subtypes. Expression thresholds were confirmed using unsupervised hierarchical clustering. Subtypes were correlated with pathology and outcomes. All NMIBC cases clustered into the basal/squamous (basal) or one of the three luminal (URO, URO-KRT5 + , and GU) subtypes. Although uncommon in this NMIBC cohort, basal tumors (3%, n = 16) had dramatically higher grade (100%, n = 16, odds ratio [OR] = 13, relative risk = 3.25) and stage, and rapid progression to muscle invasion (median progression-free survival = 35.4 months, p = 0.0001). URO, the most common subtype (46%, n = 220), showed rapid recurrence (median recurrence-free survival [RFS] = 11.5 months, p = 0.039) compared to its GU counterpart (29%, n = 137, median RFS = 16.9 months), even in patients who received intravesical immunotherapy (p = 0.049). URO-KRT5 + tumors (22%, n = 108) were typically low grade (66%, n = 71, OR = 3.7) and recurred slowly (median RFS = 38.7 months). Therefore, a simple immunohistochemical algorithm can identify clinically relevant molecular subtypes of NMIBC. In routine clinical practice, this three-antibody algorithm may help clarify diagnostic dilemmas and optimize surveillance and treatment strategies for patients.

Transcriptomic and proteomic profiling classify bladder cancers into luminal and basal molecular subtypes, with controversial prognostic and predictive associations. The complexity of published subtyping algorithms is a major impediment to understanding their biology and validating or refuting their clinical use. Here, we optimize and validate compact algorithms based on the Lund taxonomy, which separates luminal subtypes into urothelial-like (Uro) and genomically unstable (GU). We characterized immunohistochemical expression data from two muscle-invasive bladder cancer cohorts ( n=193, n=76) and developed efficient decision tree subtyping models using 4-fold cross-validation. We demonstrated that a published algorithm using routine assays (GATA3, KRT5, p16) classified basal/luminal subtypes and basal/Uro/GU subtypes with 86%–95% and 67%–86% accuracies, respectively. KRT14 and RB1 are less frequently used in pathology practice but achieved the simplest, most accurate models for basal/luminal and basal/Uro/GU discrimination, with 93%–96% and 85%–86% accuracies, respectively. More complex models with up to eight antibodies performed no better than simpler two- or three-antibody models. We conclude that simple immunohistochemistry classifiers can accurately identify luminal (Uro, GU) and basal subtypes and are appealing options for clinical implementation.

No abstract

Non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC) is significantly more common in men than women. However, female patients with NMIBC often present with more aggressive disease and do not respond as well to immunotherapy treatments. We hypothesized that sexual dimorphism in the tumor immune microenvironment (TIME) may contribute to the inferior clinical outcomes observed in female patients. To test this hypothesis, we interrogated the expression patterns of genes associated with specific immune cell types and immune regulatory pathways using tumor whole transcriptome profiles from male (n=357) and female (n=103) patients with NMIBC. High-grade tumors from female patients exhibited significantly increased expression of CD40, CTLA4, PDCD1, LAG3 and ICOS immune checkpoint genes. Based on the significant differences in expression profiles of these genes and the cell types that most commonly express these in the TIME, we evaluated the density and spatial distribution of CD8+Ki67+ (activated cytotoxic T cells), FoxP3+ (regulatory T cells), CD103+ (tissue resident T cells), CD163+ (M2-like tumor associated macrophages), CD79a+ (B cells), PD-L1+ (Programmed-Death Ligand-1) and PD-1+ cells using multiplexed immunofluorescence in an independent cohort of 332 patient tumors on a tissue microarray (n=259 males and n=73 females). Tumors from female patients showed significantly higher infiltration of CD163+ macrophages and PD-L1+ cells compared to tumors from male patients. Notably, increased infiltration of CD163+ macrophages and CD79a+ B cells independently associated with decreased recurrence free survival. Not only do these results have the potential to inform the rational utilization of immunomodulatory therapies based on the TIME of both male and female patients with NMIBC, these novel findings highlight the necessity of considering sexual dimorphism in the design of future immunotherapy trials.