For proteins of < 20 kDa, this new radical site dissociation method cleaves different and many more backbone bonds than the conventional MS/MS methods (e.g., collisionally activated dissociation, CAD) that add energy directly to the even-electron ions. A minimum kinetic energy difference between the electron and ion maximizes capture; a 1 eV difference reduces capture by 10(3). Thus, in an FTMS ion cell with added electron trapping electrodes, capture appears to be achieved best at the boundary between the potential wells that trap the electrons and ions, now providing 80 +/- 15% precursor ion conversion efficiency. Capture cross section is dependent on the ionic charge squared (z2), minimizing the secondary dissociation of lower charge fragment ions. Electron capture is postulated to occur initially at a protonated site to release an energetic (approximately 6 eV) H. atom that is captured at a high-affinity site such as -S-S- or backbone amide to cause nonergodic (before energy randomization) dissociation. Cleavages between every pair of amino acids in mellitin (2.8 kDa) and ubiquitin (8.6 kDa) are represented in their ECD and CAD spectra, providing complete data for their de novo sequencing. Because posttranslational modifications such as carboxylation, glycosylation, and sulfation are less easily lost in ECD than in CAD, ECD assignments of their sequence positions are far more specific.

Disulfide bonds in gaseous multiply-protonated proteins are preferentially cleaved in the mass spectrometer by low-energy electrons, in sharp contrast to excitation of the ions by photons or low-energy collisions. For S−S cyclized proteins, capture of one electron can break both an S−S bond and a backbone bond in the same ring, or even both disulfide bonds holding two peptide chains together (e.g., insulin), enhancing the sequence information obtainable by tandem mass spectrometry on proteins in trace amounts. Electron capture at uncharged S−S is unlikely; cleavage appears to be due to the high S−S affinity for H• atoms, consistent with a similar favorability found for tryptophan residues. RRKM calculations indicate that H• capture dissociation of backbone bonds in multiply-charged proteins represents nonergodic behavior, as proposed for the original direct mechanism of electron capture dissociation.

Electron transfer dissociation (ETD) is a recently introduced massspectrometric technique that provides a more comprehensive coverage of peptide sequences and posttranslational modifications. Here, we evaluated the use of ETD for a global phosphoproteome analysis. In all, we identified a total of 1,435 phosphorylation sites from human embryonic kidney 293T cells, of which 1,141 (Ϸ80%) were not previously described. A detailed comparison of ETD and collision-induced dissociation (CID) modes showed that ETD identified 60% more phosphopeptides than CID, with an average of 40% more fragment ions that facilitated localization of phosphorylation sites. Although our data indicate that ETD is superior to CID for phosphorylation analysis, the two methods can be effectively combined in alternating ETD and CID modes for a more comprehensive analysis. Combining ETD and CID, from this single study, we were able to identify 80% of the known phosphorylation sites in >1,000 phosphorylated peptides analyzed. A hierarchical clustering of the identified phosphorylation sites allowed us to discover 15 phosphorylation motifs that have not been reported previously. Overall, ETD is an excellent method for localization of phosphorylation sites and should be an integral component of any strategy for comprehensive phosphorylation analysis.bioinformatics ͉ motifs ͉ phosphorylation ͉ signal transduction ͉ systems biology M ost cellular processes are regulated by posttranslational modifications of proteins. For some posttranslational modifications (e.g., acetylation and tyrosine phosphorylation), identifying the modified amino acid is relatively straightforward because they are quite stable in the presence of the energy required for collisioninduced dissociation (CID) experiments. For other posttranslational modifications [e.g., O-linked N-acetylglucosamine (OGlcNAc) and phosphorylated serine and threonine residues], however, localization is substantially more difficult because the peptides either lose the modification in a charge separation process (O-GlcNAc) (1-3) or by a ␤-elimination event with a neutral loss of phosphoric acid (e.g., phosphoserine into dehydroalanine). In 1998, Zubarev et al. and Pitteri et al. (6) demonstrated that peptide cations can also be reduced and converted into radicals by reaction with radical gaseous anions, in an electron transfer process. The reduced peptides show similar fragmentation patterns as observed in ECD experiments, and the process is designated electron transfer dissociation (ETD). Although ETD has been tested in pilot experiments to localize posttranslational modifications, no large-scale analysis using ETD has yet been published.In this study, we present a global proteomic profiling of phosphopeptides subjected to fragmentation using ETD in an ion trap mass spectrometer. A total of 84,000 ETD and CID tandem MS (MS/MS) spectra from 130 liquid chromatography (LC)-MS/MS runs using three different proteolytic enzymes (Lys-C, trypsin, and Glu-C) allowed us to identify 1,435 unique phosphorylation ...

The unfolding enthalpy of the native state of ubiquitin in solution is 5 to 8 times that of its gaseous ions, as determined by electron capture dissociation (ECD) mass spectrometry. Although two-state folding occurs in solution, the three-state gaseous process proposed for this by Clemmer and co-workers based on ion mobility data is supported in general by ECD mass spectra, including relative product yields, distinct Delta H(unfolding) values between states, site-specific melting temperatures, and folding kinetics indicating a cooperative process. ECD also confirms that the 13+ ions represent separate conformers, possibly with side-chain solvated alpha-helical structures. However, the ECD data on the noncovalent bonding in the 5+ to 13+ ions, determined overall in 69 of the 75 interresidue sites, shows that thermal unfolding proceeds via a diversity of intermediates whose conformational characteristics also depend on charge site locations. As occurs with increased acidity in solution, adding 6 protons to the 5+ ions completely destroys their tertiary noncovalent bonding. However, solvation of the newly protonated sites to the backbone instead increases the stability of the secondary structure (possibly an alpha-helix) of these gaseous ions, while in solution these new sites aid denaturation by solvation in the aqueous medium. Extensive ion equilibration can lead to even more compact and diverse conformers. The three-state unfolding of gaseous ubiquitin appears to involve ensembles of individual chain conformations in a "folding funnel" of parallel reaction paths. This also provides a further caution for characterizing solution conformers from their gas-phase behavior.

In previous studies, electron capture dissociation (ECD) has been successful only with ionized smaller proteins, cleaving between 33 of the 153 amino acid pairs of a 17 kDa protein. This has been increased to 99 cleavages by colliding the ions with a background gas while subjecting them to electron capture. Presumably this ion activation breaks intramolecular noncovalent bonds of the ion's secondary and tertiary structure that otherwise prevent separation of the products from the nonergodic ECD cleavage of a backbone covalent bond. In comparison to collisionally activated dissociation, this "activated ion" (AI) ECD provides more extensive, and complementary, sequence information. AI ECD effected cleavage of 116, 60, and 47, respectively, backbone bonds in 29, 30, and 42 kDa proteins to provide extensive contiguous sequence information on both termini; AI conditions are being sought to denature the center portion of these large ions. This accurate "sequence tag" information could potentially identify individual proteins in mixtures at far lower sample levels than methods requiring prior proteolysis.