No abstract

Background. Interest in combined modality treatment and in quality of life issues may affect the choice of radical vulvectomy as the treatment of choice in many vulvar carcinomas. To evaluate the potential role of combined radiation and chemotherapy with or without local excision as primary treatment for squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva, the outcomes of 19 patients with this disease treated with combination therapy were reviewed. Methods. Nineteen patients were treated between September 1987 and October 1992. Fifteen patients had American Joint Committee on Cancer Stage III disease; 4 had Stage II. All had clinically negative inguinal lymph nodes with the exception of two patients who had positive ipsilateral inguinal nodes that were removed before treatment. The patients received 45‐50 Gy to the pelvis and inguinal nodes with concurrent chemotherapy that consisted of 5‐fluorouraciI given as a 96‐hour continuous infusion (1000 mg/m2/d) during weeks 1 and 5 of radiation. A single dose of mitomycin‐C (10 mg/m2) during the first day of chemotherapy has been used since November 1991. Ten patients were boosted with implants or electrons and 6 others underwent local excision. Results. The median follow‐up was 34 months. Responses were determined clinically 1 month after completion of the radiation and chemotherapy. Clinically, complete responses were obtained in 10 patients (53%), partial responses in 7 (37%), and no response in 1; 1 patient progressed during treatment. The combined modality therapy (radiation/chemotherapy/with or without wide local excision) resulted in a local control rate of 74% (14/19). All five treatment failures occurred within 6 months of treatment. Four of these patients were rendered disease free by radical vulvectomy and/or exenteration, for an overall local control rate of 95% (18/19). Conclusion. Concurrent radiation therapy and chemotherapy with local excision performed as needed, appears to be a reasonable alternative to radical vulvectomy in patients with primary squamous cell carcinoma of the vulva. Radical surgery remains a viable option for patients in whom primary therapy has failed.

A prospective randomized trial has compared cyclophosphamide (CTX) with CTX plus cis-diamminodichloroplatinum (DDP) as the initial chemotherapy for advanced ovarian carcinoma. A secondary randomization compared the addition of BCG treatment to either chemotherapy. The addition of DDP had no measurable impact on survival, but a small survival trend favoring BCG-treated patients was noted (P less than 0.08). Toxicity from BCG treatment was insignificant, but the addition of DDP increased both early nausea and vomiting and later hematologic toxicity. There were three long-term complete remission patients, and these all came from the group of six patients with pretreatment residual disease less than 2 cm. A univariate analysis of pretreatment prognostic factors indicated significantly better prognosis (P less than 0.02) for patients with no palpable tumor, platelet count less than 400,000/mm3, residual tumor less than 2 cm, resting pulse less than 91/min. and LDH less than 250 U/L. The authors conclude that for patients with large (greater than 2 cm) residual disease, there is no compelling evidence that initial combination therapy is superior to aggressive single alkylating agent treatment.