In the presence of the Y-chromosomal gene Sry, the bipotential mouse gonads develop as testes rather than as ovaries. The autosomal gene Sox9, a likely and possibly direct Sry target, can induce testis development in the absence of Sry. Sox9 is thus sufficient but not necessarily essential for testis induction. Mutational inactivation of one allele of SOX9/Sox9 causes sex reversal in humans but not in mice. Because Sox9(-/-) embryos die around Embryonic Day 11.5 (E11.5) at the onset of testicular morphogenesis, differentiation of the mutant XY gonad can be analyzed only ex vivo in organ culture. We have therefore conditionally inactivated both Sox9 alleles in the gonadal anlagen using the CRE/loxP recombination system, whereby CRE recombinase is under control of the cytokeratin 19 promoter. Analysis of resulting Sox9(-/-) XY gonads up to E15.5 reveals immediate, complete sex reversal, as shown by expression of the early ovary-specific markers Wnt4 and Foxl2 and by lack of testis cord and Leydig cell formation. Sry expression in mutant XY gonads indicates that downregulation of Wnt4 and Foxl2 is dependent on Sox9 rather than on Sry. Our results provide in vivo proof that, in contrast to the situation in humans, complete XY sex reversal in mice requires inactivation of both Sox9 alleles and that Sox9 is essential for testogenesis in mice.

Activation by the Y-encoded testis determining factor SRY and maintenance of expression of the Sox9 gene encoding the central transcription factor of Sertoli cell differentiation are key events in the mammalian sexual differentiation program. In the mouse XY gonad, SOX9 upregulates Fgf9, which initiates a Sox9/Fgf9 feedforward loop, and Sox9 expression is stimulated by the prostaglandin D2 (PGD2) producing lipocalin prostaglandin D synthase (L-PGDS, or PTDGS) enzyme, which accelerates commitment to the male pathway. In an attempt to decipher the genetic relationships between Sox9 and the L-Pgds/PGD2 pathway during mouse testicular organogenesis, we found that ablation of Sox9 at the onset or during the time window of expression in embryonic Sertoli cells abolished L-Pgds transcription. By contrast, L-Pgds -/-XY embryonic gonads displayed a reduced level of Sox9 transcript and aberrant SOX9 protein subcellular localization. In this study, we demonstrated genetically that the L-Pgds/PGD2 pathway acts as a second amplification loop of Sox9 expression. Moreover, examination of Fgf9 -/-and L-Pgds -/-XY embryonic gonads demonstrated that the two Sox9 gene activity amplifying pathways work independently. These data suggest that, once activated and maintained by SOX9, production of testicular L-PGDS leads to the accumulation of PGD2, which in turn activates Sox9 transcription and nuclear translocation of SOX9. This mechanism participates together with FGF9 as an amplification system of Sox9 gene expression and activity during mammalian testicular organogenesis.

Sox9 and Sox8 are transcription factors expressed in embryonic and postnatal Sertoli cells of the mouse testis. Sox9 inactivation prior to the sex determination stage leads to complete XY sex reversal. In contrast, there is normal embryonic testis development in Sox8 mutants which are initially fertile, but later develop progressive seminiferous tubule failure and infertility. To determine whether Sox9 is required for testis development after the initial steps of sex determination, we crossed Sox9(flox) mice with an AMH-Cre transgenic line thereby completely deleting Sox9 in Sertoli cells by E14.0. Conditional Sox9 null mutants show normal embryonic testis development and are initially fertile, but, like Sox8(-/-) mutants, become sterile from dysfunctional spermatogenesis at about 5 months. To see whether Sox8 may compensate for the absence of Sox9 during embryonic testis differentiation, we generated a Sox9 conditional knockout on a Sox8 mutant background. In the double mutants, differentiation of testis cords into seminiferous testis tubules ceases after P6 in the absence of one Sox8 allele, and after P0 in the absence of both Sox8 alleles, leading to complete primary infertility. Sox9,Sox8 double nullizygous testes show upregulation of early ovary-specific markers and downregulation of Sertoli intercellular junctions at E15.5. Their very low Amh levels still cause complete regression of the Müllerian duct but with reduced penetrance. This study shows that testis cord differentiation is independent of Sox9, and that concerted Sox9 and Sox8 function in post E14.0 Sertoli cells is essential for the maintenance of testicular function.

SOX9 is an evolutionary conserved transcription factor that is expressed in a variety of tissues, with essential functions in cartilage, testis, heart, glial cell, inner ear and neural crest development. By comparing human and pufferfish genomic sequences, we previously identified eight highly conserved sequence elements between 290 kb 5' and 450 kb 3' to human SOX9. In this study, we assayed the regulatory potential of elements E1 to E7 in transgenic mice using a lacZ reporter gene driven by a 529 bp minimal mouse Sox9 promoter. We found that three of these elements and the Sox9 promoter control distinct subsets of the tissue-specific expression pattern of Sox9. E3, located 251 kb 5' to SOX9, directs lacZ expression to cranial neural crest cells and to the inner ear. E1 is located 28 kb 5' to SOX9 and controls expression in the node, notochord, gut, bronchial epithelium and pancreas. Transgene expression in the neuroectoderm is mediated by E7, located 95 kb 3' to SOX9, which regulates expression in the telencephalon and midbrain, and by the Sox9 minimal promoter which controls expression in the ventral spinal cord and hindbrain. We show that E3-directed reporter gene expression in neural crest cells of the first but not of the second and third pharyngeal arch is dependent on beta-catenin, revealing a complex regulation of Sox9 in cranial neural crest cells. Moreover, we identify and discuss highly conserved transcription factor binding sites within enhancer E3 that are in good agreement with current models for neural crest and inner ear development. Finally, we identify enhancer E1 as a cis-regulatory element conserved between vertebrates and invertebrates, indicating that some cis-regulatory sequences that control developmental genes in vertebrates might be phylogenetically ancient.

No abstract