Although subduction zones are the main source of seismic and volcanic hazards on Earth, the causes of melting in volcanic arcs are still not fully understood. Recent models suggested that melting in the mantle wedge is not caused by hydrous fluids, but by sediment melts ascending from the subducted slab. A main argument for these models was that hydrous fluids are "too dilute" to produce the trace element enrichment observed in arc magmas. Here we demonstrate experimentally that even moderate salinities enhance the partitioning of trace elements such as the light rare earths, alkalis, alkaline earths, Pb, and U into the fluid by several orders of magnitude. Our data therefore show that saline hydrous fluids released from the basaltic part of the oceanic crust may produce the enrichment in LILE and light REE elements, and the negative Nb-Ta anomaly observed in typical arc magmas.

No abstract

The partitioning of major and trace elements between eclogite and aqueous fluids with variable salinity was studied at 700–800 °C and 4–6 GPa in piston cylinder and multi anvil experiments. Fluid compositions were determined using the diamond trap technique combined with laser ablation ICP-MS measurements in the frozen state. In addition to NaCl, SiO2 is the main solute in the fluids. The fluid/eclogite partition coefficients of the large ion lithophile elements (LILE), such as Rb, Cs, Sr, and Ba as well as those of the light rare earths (LREE), of Pb, and of U increase by up to three orders of magnitude with salinity. These elements will therefore be efficiently transported by saline fluids. On the other hand, typical high field strength elements, such as Ti, Nb, and Ta, are not mobilized even at high salinities. Increasing temperature and pressure gradually increases the partitioning into the fluid. In particular, Th is mobilized by silica-rich fluids at 6 GPa already at low salinities. We show that we can fully reproduce the trace element enrichment pattern of primitive arc basalts by adding a few percent of saline fluid (with 5–10 wt% Cl) released from the basaltic slab to the zone of melting in the mantle wedge. Assuming 2 wt% of rutile in the eclogite equilibrated with the saline fluid produces a negative Nb Ta anomaly that is larger than in most primitive arc basalts. Therefore, we conclude that the rutile fraction in the subducted eclogite below most arcs is likely < 1 wt%. In fact, saline fluids would even produce a noticeable negative Nb Ta anomaly without any rutile in the eclogite residue. Metasomatism by sediment melts alone, on the other hand, is unable to produce the enrichment pattern seen in arc basalts. We, therefore, conclude that at least for primitive arc basalts, the release of hydrous fluids from the basaltic part of the subducted slab is the trigger for melting and the main agent of trace element enrichment. The contribution of sediment melts to the petrogenesis of these magmas is likely negligible. In the supplementary material, we provide a “Subduction Calculator” in Excel format, which allows the calculation of the trace element abundance pattern in primitive arc basalts as function of fluid salinity, the amount of fluid released from the basaltic part of the subducted slab, the fluid fraction added to the source, and the degree of melting.

A variety of experimental techniques have been proposed to measure the composition of aqueous fluids in high-pressure experiments. In particular, the “diamond trap method,” where the fluid is sampled in the pore space of diamond powder and analyzed by laser-ablation ICP-MS after the experiment, has become a popular tool. Here, we carried out several tests to assess the reliability of this method. (1) We prepared several capsules loaded with fluid of known composition and analyzed the fluid by laser-ablation ICP-MS, either (a) after drying the diamond trap at ambient condition; (b) after freezing and subsequent freeze-drying; and (c) after freezing and by analyzing a frozen state. Of these methods, the analysis in the frozen state (c) was most accurate, while the results from the other two methods were poorly reproducible, and the averages sometimes deviated from the expected composition by more than a factor of 2. (2) We tested the reliability of the diamond trap method by using it to measure mineral solubilities in some well-studied systems at high pressure and high temperature in piston-cylinder runs. In the systems quartz-H2O, forsterite-enstatite-H2O, and albite-H2O, the results from analyzing the diamond trap in a frozen state by laser-ablation ICP-MS generally agreed well with the expected compositions according to literature data. However, in the systems corundum-H2O and rutile-H2O, the data from the analysis of the diamond trap were poorly reproducible and appeared to indicate much higher solubilities than expected. We attribute this not to some unreliability of the analytical method, but instead to the fact that in these systems, minor temperature gradients along the capsule may induce the dissolution and re-precipitation of material during the run, which causes a contamination of the diamond trap by solid phases. (3) We carried out several tests on the reliability of the diamond trap to measure fluid compositions and trace element partition coefficients in the eclogite-fluid system at 4 GPa and 800 °C using piston-cylinder experiments. The good agreement between “forward” and “reversed” experiments—with trace elements initially either doped in the solid starting material or the fluid—as well as the independence of partition coefficients on bulk concentrations suggests that the data obtained are reliable in most cases. We also show that the rate of quenching/cooling has little effect on the analytical results, that temperature oscillations during the run can be used to enhance grain growth, and that well-equilibrated samples can be obtained in conventional piston-cylinder runs. Overall, our results suggest that the diamond trap method combined with laser-ablation ICP-MS in frozen state yields reliable results accurate within a factor of two in most cases; however, the precipitation of accessory minerals in the diamond trap during the run may severely affect the data in some systems and may lead to a gross overestimation of fluid concentrations.