No abstract

No abstract

Objective: To evaluate a fully automated system for liquid-based cytology (LBC): the NovaPrep® Processor System (NPS), which is based on the new concept of double decantation, versus conventional cytology (CC), the gold standard for cytology. Study Design: We performed a preliminary comparative study involving 1,129 female patients who underwent sampling for a Pap test; the sample was first smeared for CC and then, using the remaining specimen on the brush, for LBC with the NPS. The performances of CC and NPS were evaluated for accuracy and compared using the gold standard of a combination of one of the two methods of pathological cytology with screening for positive human papilloma virus, quantification of cells (normal and pathological), and improvement in the quality of samples and reading time. Results: The results showed improvement in sensitivity (3.81% for CC vs. 4.52% for NPS) with a specificity superior to 90% for both, a markedly decreased number of unsatisfactory specimens, notably samples containing too many inflamed cells (7.4% for CC vs. 0.5% for NPS), and a shortening of the reading time, which was three times less using NPS. Conclusion: This preliminary study showed a gain in sensitivity, a drop in the number of unsatisfactory specimens and a reduction in reading time with NPS. The results achieved using this fully automated LBC procedure are very promising and will hopefully reduce the overall cost of cervical cancer screening in the future.

No abstract

Context and setting Expert system programs follow the same rational steps as a human expert to solve a specific problem. Their use in teaching may be effective, as users can learn by observing the behaviour of the system. We developed an expert system for lymphoid pathology diagnosis, based on pattern recognition, the key to diagnosis in pathology. Why the idea was necessary A recent call for novel computer-based approaches to the teaching of pathology in European schools of medicine prompted our group to adapt and test our expert system for this purpose. What was done The modified expert system for lymphoid pathology knowledge (SEACOPALI) shows images selected for their similarity to a problem case. According to the pattern selected, further patterns and descriptive and diagnostic data are presented, requiring the user to focus on specific characteristics and offering differential diagnoses. A study was performed with 3 groups of 3rd-year medical students (n ¼ 101 students) who used either the SEACOPALI system, or SEACOPALI documentation or lymphoid pathology text plus ATLAS. Students were tested on their existing knowledge (pretest), after which they completed a questionnaire on 4 clinical cases using their respective learning resources (computer system or documentation or traditional materials). This was immediately followed by a second test of their knowledge (post-test). The expert system group also completed a questionnaire on the usability of the system. Evaluation of results and impact Performance of the test itself impacted positively on knowledge acquisition (correct results: 27AE5% pretest versus 56AE6% posttest), as reported in previous studies of problembased learning strategies. The expert system group achieved the highest level of learning in the histological diagnosis of low-and high-grade lymphomas (P < 0AE05). The groups did not differ in their ability to diagnose Hodgkin's lymphoma, but the expert system and the expert system documentation groups showed greater skill in pattern recognition than the traditional learners (P < 0AE001); 68AE6% of the expert system group said they would recommend its use to their peers and 42AE9% indicated they would like to use the system daily. Results were validated by using the Kruskal-Wallis non-parametric test. These preliminary results indicate that use of the expert system assists acquisition of practical knowledge and pattern recognition and that the system would be optimally used as a complement to traditional teaching. The need for modifications to the system was revealed by the study, leading to the development of a new expert system prototype that incorporates a screen to display problem cases and can be used interactively by the student. Research by pre-clinical undergraduate medical students G JoubertContext and setting At the University of the Free State (UFS), Bloemfontein, South Africa a new 5-year undergraduate teaching programme for medical students was introduced in 2000 to replace the previous 6-year programme. In the knowledge, attitudinal ...