Traditionally, the design coordination process
is carried out by overlaying and comparing 2D drawings
made by different project participants. Detecting information
errors from a composite drawing is especially challenging
and error prone. This procedure usually leaves
many design errors undetected until construction begins,
and typically lead to rework. Correcting conflict issues,
which were not identified during design and coordination
phase, reduces the overall productivity for everyone involved
in the construction process. The identification of
construction issues in the field generate Request for Information
(RFIs) that is one of delays causes. The application
of Virtual Design and Construction (VDC) tools to the coordination
processes can bring significant value to architecture,
structure, and mechanical, electrical, and plumbing
(MEP) designs in terms of a reduced number of errors
undetected and requests for information. This paper is focused
on evaluating requests for information (RFI) associated
with water/sanitary facilities of a BIM model. Thus,
it is expected to add improvements of water/sanitary facility
designs, as well as to assist the virtual construction
team to notice and identify design problems. This is an exploratory
and descriptive research. A qualitative methodology
is used. This study adopts RFI’s classification in six analyzed categories: correction, omission, validation of
information, modification, divergence of information and
verification. The results demonstrate VDC’s contribution
improving the plumbing system designs. Recommendations
are suggested to identify and avoid these RFI types
in plumbing system design process or during virtual construction.
Request For Information (RFI) is a communication tool to facilitate resolution of, or to clarify, construction issues. Traditionally, construction teams generate RFIs, but with BIM they are anticipated being generated before construction by designers. The aim of this study to improve the understanding of how design conflicts happen through the lenses of RFI and motivate a proactive design review approach. The study was developed as a case study of RFI distribution and classification in the design of residential towers using a Virtual Design and Construction (VDC) approach. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with the virtual construction team coordinator. The interviews were transcribed and transformed in process map, especially, explicating how Request For Information was generated and how the interaction among the participants occurs. A documental analysis was performed on coordination models characterizing the type of RFI, its location, and quantity distribution within design discipline. The design process map drawn shows a partially implemented VDC where design developed with traditional CAD tools benefits from a design review process developed with virtual prototyping and 3D coordination with BIM tools. The distribution patterns of RFI quantities denote where the greatest effort in the review was, exposing design complexity. The analysis here presented may be applied to new situations other than those studied in order to promote learning within and metrics for VDC.
Keywords
How to cite this article:DANTAS FILHO, João Bosco Pinheiro et al. BIM based requests for information classification and distribution: two residential tower cases.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.