Catheter-related bloodstream infections are among the lethal complications of central venous catheter use. Patients with end-stage kidney disease use tunneled dialysis catheters (TDC) in the absence of arteriovenous access. We report a case of a patient using a TDC who developed panophthalmitis. This patient presented with painful and swollen eyes, fever, and chills. Positive methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA) blood cultures were thought to be secondary to a catheter-related bloodstream infection originating from his TDC. A maxillofacial computed tomography scan showed an enlarged, elongated, and proptotic left globe with suspected scleral irregularity suggestive of panophthalmitis. Despite TDC removal and systemic antibiotics, his left eye had to be enucleated. A new TDC was placed after treating the catheter-related bloodstream infection. He continued antibiotic therapy for a total of eight weeks. Panophthalmitis, a rare complication of catheter-related bloodstream infection among hemodialysis patients using a TDC, represents another reason to avoid TDC as hemodialysis access.