Problem solving based on compiled associations between elements of the decision space and data is an efficient mode of reasoning for a large percentage of situations faced by an expert. But in some (usually small) percentage of cases, compiled associations are not enough by themselves to lead to correct results. Reasoning from "deeper" levels of understanding offers the advantage ofproducing correct results even in atypical cases, but at the cost of expanding more computational resources. Thus the trade-offbetween compiled level systems and deep level systems is between computational efficiency (at the compiled level) and problem-solving generality (at the deep level). JIi, describe a hybrid system containing elements of both deep level reasoning and compiled level reasoning. More particularly, we propose a problem-solving architecture for category-based diagnostic problem solving which at the compiled level centers on classification problem solving and at the deep level uses a type offunction-based reasoning. We concentrate in this report on the interaction between the compiled and deep level units and on the mechanisms offunction-based reasoning that we employ. We show how our function-based consequence-finding problem solver can be focused by problem solving at the compiled level and how, through such interaction, we obtain the computational efficiency characteristic of compiled level problem solving while retaining the robustness characteristic of deep level problem solving.We thank Mr. Dean Allemang for his very useful commenls during the early stages of this work. In addition, Dr. Tom Bylander spent considerable time reviewing early drafts. Finally, we are indebted to both Dr. Sanjay Mittal and Dr. Fernando Gomez for Iheir contributions to the original MDX approach and system, which paved the way for the MDX2 system.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.