This study investigated similarities and differences in the experience of auditory hallucinations, paranoia, and childhood trauma in schizophrenia and borderline personality disorder (BPD). Patients with clinical diagnoses of schizophrenia or BPD were interviewed using the Structured Clinical Interviews for DSM-IV. Axes 1 and 2 and auditory hallucinations, paranoia, and childhood trauma were assessed. A total of 111 patients participated; 59 met criteria for schizophrenia, 33 for BPD, and 19 for both. The groups were similar in their experiences of voices, including the perceived location of them, but they differed in frequency of paranoid delusions. Those with a diagnosis of BPD, including those with schizophrenia comorbidity, reported more childhood trauma, especially emotional abuse. BPD and schizophrenia frequently coexist, and this comorbidity has implications for diagnostic classification and treatment. Levels of reported childhood trauma are especially high in those with a BPD diagnosis, whether they have schizophrenia or not, and this requires assessment and appropriate management.

Auditory hallucinations in psychosis and BPD do not differ in their phenomenology or cognitive responses (beliefs about the power and malevolence of their dominant voice). The main differential appears to be the affective response. CBT that focuses on appraisals and the relationship with voices may be helpful for distressing auditory hallucinations in individuals with BPD as well as psychosis.

The frequency of reports of childhood trauma would appear to be higher amongst adults with a diagnosis of BD compared with individuals with no psychiatric diagnoses. Levels of internalized shame in adulthood are also likely to be higher than those in the general population, although the current literature does not shed light on the relationship between childhood abuse and neglect, mood-related behaviour, and shame. Experiences of childhood abuse and neglect, particularly childhood emotional abuse and emotional neglect, are likely to be frequently reported by clients with a diagnosis of BD. Clinicians should therefore explicitly consider these experiences in their assessment, formulation and intervention with clients with a diagnosis of BD.

All participants reported subjective benefits and challenges of mindfulness practice, and gave insights into processes of change. These preliminary data suggest mindfulness can be of use to individuals experiencing their first episode of psychosis.

BACKGROUND. A metacognitive approach to the conceptualization of paranoia as a strategy for managing interpersonal threat has gained some support in studies of non-clinical populations. This study reports a clinical validation of the Beliefs about Paranoia Scale (BaPS), a self-report measure to assess metacognitive beliefs about paranoia. We aimed to replicate the factor structure of a brief version of the measure and test the specific hypotheses that positive beliefs about paranoia would predict levels of suspiciousness, and that negative beliefs about paranoia would predict problematic persecutory delusions. METHOD. A total of 122 patients meeting criteria for a diagnosis of a schizophrenia spectrum disorder completed the questionnaire assessing beliefs about paranoia. In addition, 61 of the participants were administered the Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-IV, and 60 were administered the Positive and Negative Syndromes of Schizophrenia Scale. One hundred and seventy-eight non-patients were also recruited (an undergraduate sample). RESULTS. Principal components factor analysis showed that the three-factor solution was replicated (comprising negative beliefs about paranoia, paranoia as a survival strategy, and normalizing beliefs). This measure showed good internal consistency (alphas ranged from .85 to .91). Correlational analyses revealed that positive beliefs about paranoia were positively associated with levels of suspiciousness, and independent t tests showed that negative beliefs about paranoia were significantly higher in patients with a diagnosis of schizophrenia meeting criteria for persecutory delusions in comparison to those without. Analyses of covariance showed that patients scored higher than non-patients on both positive and negative beliefs, but logistic regression did not demonstrate that co-occurrence of these beliefs predicted patient status. CONCLUSIONS. Three of our four hypotheses were confirmed, suggesting that a metacognitive approach to the conceptualization of paranoia as a strategy for managing interpersonal threat may have some utility for understanding clinical paranoia. Such a model is described and the clinical implications of the findings are also discussed.