Older adult outpatients with major depression (« = 25) and healthy control subjects (n = 25) were compared using the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS) and the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI). Both measures were sensitive in detecting clinical depression. Subjects were, however, more likely to endorse multiple responses on BDI items, suggesting that the GDS is simpler for older adults to complete. Viewed within the context of previous relevant research that used these instruments to compare older adults, our results yield additional evidence of cross-study consistency in the functional efficiency of both measures.Two of the most popular self-report measures of depression currently used are the Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS; Yesavage et al., 1983) and the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI; Beck, Rush, Shaw, & Emery, 1979). Yet, in the elderly, their relative efficiencies as screening instruments for major depression have been assessed solely in Veterans Administration (VA) samples of male psychiatric inpatients (Hyer & Blount, 1984), medical inpatients (Morris, Gallagher, Wilson, & Winograd, 1987), and medical outpatients (Rapp, Parisi, Walsh, & Wallace, 1988), but not in psychiatric outpatients.Functional efficiency, the accuracy with which a screening instrument can distinguish one group of subjects (e.g., depressed elderly) from another, was estimated for the GDS and BDI by comparing healthy, older-adult male and female outpatients with major depression to age-and gender-matched control subjects. In addition, because the Somatic subscale on the BDI might increase the likelihood of false-positive diagnoses in older adults (Hyer & Blount, 1984), and because the true-false format of the GDS might be simpler for older adults to complete than the multiple-choice format of the BDI (Norris et al, 1987), item-response properties, the style in which individual items are completed, were examined.
Method
SubjectsSubjects (N = 50) were community-dwelling male and female older adults (mean age = 64.2, SD -5.36, range = 56-77 years), recruited