There is a consensus regarding the fact that students encounter difficulties in understanding scientific concepts, such as the particulate nature of matter, the mole, and the interpretation of chemical symbols. Researchers and practitioners have been looking for teaching methods to improve students' understanding of quantitative chemistry and their ability to solve related problems. This study describes the Multidimensional Analysis System (MAS), an approach to constructing, classifying, and analyzing quantitative chemistry problems. MAS enables classification based on complexity and transformation levels of a quantitative problem. We define three transformation levels: symbol $ macro, symbol $ micro, and symbol $ process. Applying this framework to teaching and research, we investigated the relationships between MAS-classified chemistry problems and student achievement in solving these problems. The research population, 241 high school chemistry students, studied problem solving according to MAS for 9 weeks; the control group studied the same topic for the same duration in the traditional way. Student achievement was sorted by mathematics level and gender. We found that the success rate of the entire student population in solving these problems decreased as the problem difficulty increased. Experimental group students scored significantly higher than their control group peers. The improvement in student achievement was significantly dependent on the pretest score and the mathematics level, and independent of gender. Students who studied mathematics in the basic level benefited significantly more from MAS-based teaching than their peers, whose mathematics level was advanced. Based on the research findings, we recommend applying the multidimensional analysis approach while teaching quantitative problems in chemistry. ß Chemical education is a complex human endeavor which involves deep understanding of diverse concepts and requires a mental transfer between several modes of representation.
The mole is a fundamental concept in chemistry. It
is a basic measurement unit and is used for stoichiometric
calculations, expressing solution concentrations, equilibrium constant,
and pH. Many students have difficulties
in understanding and applying the mole concept. Students therefore
adopt a variety of algorithmic techniques
for solving problems provided as predefined templates in books,
classes, tests, and matriculation examinations.
Consequently, some of the students are not capable of solving
complicated problems which do not conform
with any of the templates they recognize. Having identified these
problems, we have developed a studyware
referred to as “The Mole Environment”. This studyware
integrates two approaches: (1) continuous, real-time feedback to the student responses and (2) incorporating real-life
problems from the domains of
environmental studies, chemical industry, and medicine. The
studyware includes problems at several cognitive
levels which progress in difficulty and complexity. The
development, implementation in high school and
in-service teachers' training, and evaluation are presented and
discussed.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.