Establishment of mixed chimerism through transplantation of allogeneic donor bone marrow (BM) into sufficiently conditioned recipients is an effective experimental approach for the induction of transplantation tolerance. Clinical translation, however, is impeded by the lack of feasible protocols devoid of cytoreductive conditioning (i.e. irradiation and cytotoxic drugs/mAbs). The therapeutic application of regulatory T cells (Tregs) prolongs allograft survival in experimental models, but appears insufficient to induce robust tolerance on its own. We thus investigated whether mixed chimerism and tolerance could be realized without the need for cytoreductive treatment by combining Treg therapy with BM transplantation (BMT). Polyclonal recipient Tregs were cotransplanted with a moderate dose of fully mismatched allogeneic donor BM into recipients conditioned solely with short-course costimulation blockade and rapamycin. This combination treatment led to long-term multilineage chimerism and donor-specific skin graft tolerance. Chimeras also developed humoral and in vitro tolerance. Both deletional and nondeletional mechanisms contributed to maintenance of tolerance. All tested populations of polyclonal Tregs (FoxP3-transduced Tregs, natural Tregs and TGF-β induced Tregs) were effective in this setting. Thus, Treg therapy achieves mixed chimerism and tolerance without cytoreductive recipient treatment, thereby eliminating a major toxic element impeding clinical translation of this approach.

The major factors that limit the success of organ transplantation are the host immune response to the foreign graft and the adverse effects of the chronic immunosuppressive therapy required to suppress this immune response. Deliberately establishing tolerance towards the donor tissue by reprogramming the immune system of the recipient thus holds great promise in improving organ transplant survival and eliminating the untoward effects of chronic drug therapy. The transplantation of donor bone marrow into recipients who are appropriately conditioned to allow development of either full or mixed chimerism has long been recognized to effectively induce donor-specific tolerance. Despite the demonstrated effectiveness of this technique, use of the mixed chimerism strategy in regular clinical practice has been hampered by the toxic side effects inherent to conventional bone marrow transplantation protocols. This Review addresses recent advances in preclinical and clinical studies inducing transplantation tolerance through mixed chimerism and discusses both the potential and the challenges of this approach.

Highlights► Costimulatory pathways have a critical role in the regulation of alloreactivity. ► A complex network of positive and negative pathways regulates T cell responses. ► Blocking costimulation improves allograft survival in rodents and non-human primates. ► The costimulation blocker belatacept is being developed as immunosuppressive drug in renal transplantation.

BackgroundThe mixed chimerism approach induces donor-specific tolerance in both pre-clinical models and clinical pilot trials. However, chronic rejection of heart allografts and acute rejection of skin allografts were observed in some chimeric animals despite persistent hematopoietic chimerism and tolerance toward donor antigens in vitro. We tested whether additional cell therapy with regulatory T cells (Tregs) is able to induce full immunologic tolerance and prevent chronic rejection.MethodsWe recently developed a murine “Treg bone marrow (BM) transplantation (BMT) protocol” that is devoid of cytoreductive recipient pre-treatment. The protocol consists of a moderate dose of fully mismatched allogeneic donor BM under costimulation blockade, together with polyclonal recipient Tregs and rapamycin. Control groups received BMT under non-myeloablative irradiation and costimulation blockade without Treg therapy. Multilineage chimerism was followed by flow cytometry, and tolerance was assessed by donor-specific skin and heart allografts.ResultsDurable multilineage chimerism and long-term donor skin and heart allograft survival were successfully achieved with both protocols. Notably, histologic examination of heart allografts at the end of follow-up revealed that chronic rejection is prevented only in chimeras induced with the Treg protocol.ConclusionsIn a mouse model of mixed chimerism, additional Treg treatment at the time of BMT prevents chronic rejection of heart allografts. As the Treg-chimerism protocol also obviates the need for cytoreductive recipient treatment it improves both efficacy and safety over previous non-myeloablative mixed chimerism regimens. These results may significantly impact the development of protocols for tolerance induction in cardiac transplantation.