Arising from cryogenic electron microscopy image analysis, "Einstein from noise" is a phenomenon of significant statistical interest because spurious patterns could easily emerge by averaging a large number of white-noise images aligned to a reference image through rotation and translation. While this phenomenon is often attributed to model bias, quantitative studies on such a bias are lacking. Here, we introduce a simple framework under which an image of p pixels is treated as a vector of dimension p and a white-noise image is a random vector uniformly sampled from the (p − 1)-dimensional unit sphere. Moreover, we adopt the cross correlation of two images which is a similarity measure based on the dot product of image pixels. This framework geometrically explains how the bias results from averaging a properly chosen set of white-noise images that are most highly cross-correlated with the reference image. We quantify the bias in terms of three parameters: the number of white-noise images (n), the image dimension (p), and the size of the selection set (m). Under the conditions that n, p and m are all large and (ln n) 2 /p and m/n are both small, we show that the bias is approximately 2γ 1+2γ where γ = m p ln n m .
This paper introduces a new approach, which combines empirical Bayes modeling with recent advances in Markov chain Monte Carlo filters for hidden Markov models, to address long-standing challenging problems in reconstruction of 3D images, with uncertainty quantification, from noisy 2D pixels in cryogenic electron microscopy and other applications such as brain network development in infants.
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.