A new optimization method called grazer search has been developed. This method is suitable for nonlinear minimsx optimization of network and system responses. A linear programming problem using gradient information of one or more highest ripples in the response error function to produce a downhill direction followed by a linear search to find a mkdmum in that direction is central to the algorithm.Unlike the razor search method due to Bandler and Macdonald, the present method overcomes the problem of dkcontinuous derivatives characteristic of minimax objectives without using random moves. It can fully exploit the advantages of the adjoint network method of evaluating partial derivatives of the response function with respect to the variable parameters. Sutllcient details are given to enable the grazer search method to be readily programmed and used. Although the method is intended for the computer-aided solution of an extremely wide range of design problems, it is largely compared with other methods on microwave network design problems, for which the solutions are known. Its reliability and efficiency on more arbitrary problems, examples of which are also included, is thereby established.
Some recently proposotl gradiont motliods for minimax or near minimax approximation are applied to producing optimal second-order and third-order models of a highorder system. The Fletcher-Powell method, a more recont method by k'letchcr and a mcthod hy Jacobson and Oksman are employcd with least pth appro xi ma ti or^, using largc valocs of p , as proposed by Ranrller and Charalambous and critically compared with t,hc graaor search tcchniquc of minimas approximation by Bandler ct al. The solutions ohtniztccl nre shown to satisfy t,hc necessary conditions for a minimax optimum.
IntroductionThe purpose of determining low-order models for high-order systems is t o simplify preliminary design and optimization of such systems. System modelling using least-squares approximation has been investigated recently by Bn,ndler et ul. ( 1072 a). They compared, in particular, the relative cffeciencies of three gradient minimiza,tion methods as applied t o least squares problems. The system modelled was a seventh-order system which represents tlic control system for the pitch rate of a supersonic transport aircraft.In the present work, the maximum value of the error between the step responses of the above seventh-order system and the model is effectively minimized. This may be accomplished either by directly minimizing the maximum error (minimax), or by least ptli approximatiou techniques which, by selecting a large enough value for p, gives, for practical purposes, a minimax solution. The direct minimax method, called the grazor search teclmique, has been recently proposed by Bandler, Srinirasan and Charalambous (1972 c). The strategy is based on steepest descent directions found by linear programniing. The least ptli approximation approach was based on a paper by Handler and Charalambous (1971) where very large values of p-up to 113'~-11ave been successfnlly used. For the presmt problem the value of p was ehoscn as 1000, on the bask of acceptable alinost minimax results and reasonable eomputcr central processing time. A comparison is made between three
scite is a Brooklyn-based organization that helps researchers better discover and understand research articles through Smart Citations–citations that display the context of the citation and describe whether the article provides supporting or contrasting evidence. scite is used by students and researchers from around the world and is funded in part by the National Science Foundation and the National Institute on Drug Abuse of the National Institutes of Health.