Purpose Osteochondral talar lesions, regardless of their size and/or chronicity, are, at our hospital, now treated by fixation of the fragment if the talar dome cartilage is judged to be healthy. The retrospective study described herein was conducted to assess clinical outcomes of this treatment strategy. Methods The study group comprised 44 patients (18 men and 26 women) with 45 such talar lesions. In all cases, the osteochondral fragment was reduced and fixed with bone harvested from the osteotomy site and shaped into peg(s) (one to four pegs per lesion). Median follow‐up was 2.1 years (1–9 years). The lesion area was measured on computed tomography arthrographs, and the Japanese Society for Surgery of the Foot (JSSF) ankle/hindfoot scale was used to evaluate postoperative outcomes. Clinical failure was defined as a JSSF score < 80 points. Results The mean JSSF score improved significantly from 63.5 points preoperatively to 93.0 postoperatively (p < 0.001). Treatment failure occurred in only one ankle (0.02%). The mean lesion area was 51.2 mm2 (range 5–147 mm2). Correlation between lesion areas and the postoperative JSSF scores was weak (r = − 0.133). Correlation between the time of the trauma to the time of fixation surgery and the postoperative JSSF scores was also weak (r = 0.042). Radiographic outcomes were good for 28 ankles, fair for 10, and poor for 7. Conclusion Fixation of the lesion fragment, regardless of size and/or chronicity, appears to be appropriate in cases of an osteochondral talar lesion. Level of evidence IV.