Objective This was a randomized controlled trial to test efficacy of a telephone intervention (TBMI) for injured ED patients with alcohol misuse to decrease alcohol use, impaired driving, alcohol-related injuries and alcohol-related negative consequences. Methods ED patients screening positive for alcohol misuse were randomized to a three-session telephone brief motivational intervention on alcohol (TBMI) delivered by a counselor trained in motivational interviewing over 6 weeks or a control intervention of a scripted home fire and burn safety education delivered in three calls. Patients were followed for 12 months and assessed for changes in alcohol use, impaired driving, alcohol-related injuries and alcohol-related negative consequences. Results 730 ED patients were randomized; 78% received their assigned intervention by telephone and of those, 72% completed 12 months assessments. There were no differential benefits of TBMI intervention versus assessment and a control intervention in all three variables of alcohol use (frequency of binge alcohol use over the prior 30 days, maximum number of drinks at one time in past 30 days, typical alcohol use in past 30 days), alcohol impaired driving, alcohol related injuries and alcohol-related negative consequences. Conclusions Despite the potential advantage of delivering a TBMI in not disrupting ED clinical care, our study found no efficacy for it over an assessment and control intervention. Potential etiologies for our finding include that injury itself or alcohol assessments, or the control intervention had active ingredients for alcohol change.

IntroductionSurvey data regarding the prevalence of risky substance use in the emergency department (ED) is not consistent. The objective of this study was to identify the prevalence of risky substance use among injured ED patients based on the Alcohol, Smoking and Substance Involvement Screening Test (ASSIST v3.0). A secondary objective was to report on the feasibility of administering the ASSIST to this population, based on the time to conduct screening.MethodsThis cross-sectional study used screening data from a randomized controlled trial. Injured ED patients completed the ASSIST on a tablet computer, and an ASSIST score was computed that indicated the need for a brief or intensive treatment intervention (risky use) for alcohol and other substances. For a subsample, data on time to complete each step of screening was recorded.ResultsBetween July 2010 and March 2013, 5,695 patients completed the ASSIST. Most (92%) reported lifetime use of at least one substance and 51% reported current risky use of at least one substance. Mean time to complete the ASSIST was 5.4 minutes and screening was considered feasible even when paused for clinical care to proceed.ConclusionEstimates of risky substance use based on the ASSIST in our large sample of injured ED patients were higher than previously reported in other studies of ED patients, possibly due to the current focus on an injured population. In addition, it was feasible to administer the ASSIST to patients in the course of their clinical care.