Disks made of hydroxyapatite, beta-tricalcium phosphate, carbonate apatite, tetracalcium phosphate, alpha-tricalcium phosphate, dicalcium phosphate dihydrate, and octacalcium phosphate were incubated in osteoclastic cell cultures for 2 days. The first five salts were sintered and the last two were compressed before incubation. Osteoclasts resorbed only the sintered carbonate apatite disks. However, osteoclasts were able to resorb octacalcium phosphate disks that were preincubated for 1 day in medium without cells, indicating that surface conditioning was important for osteoclastic resorption of this calcium phosphate. Although resorption did not occur, medium calcium and phosphorus changed to an appreciable extent after a 2-day incubation of beta-tricalcium phosphate, tetracalcium phosphate, alpha-tricalcium phosphate, and dicalcium phosphate dihydrate. These changes in the medium calcium and phosphate concentrations could explain why osteoclasts appeared to have lost their activity on these calcium phosphate disks and were not capable of resorbing them. With hydroxyapatite disks no changes were observed in the medium calcium and phosphorus before and after incubation. Moreover, the osteoclasts appeared to be essentially the same as with the sintered carbonate apatite disks and with bone slices used as a control. Nevertheless, no pits or lacunae were observed on the hydroxyapatite disks, indicating that sintered carbonate apatite should be superior to sintered hydroxyapatite as a bioresorbable bone substitute.

The dissolution behavior of sintered carbonate apatite was investigated in a 10 mM/L acetic acid solution adjusted to pH 5.0 at 37 degrees C, and compared to that of sintered hydroxyapatite and bone apatite for the purpose of establishing some similarities between the physicochemical dissolution of apatite biomaterials in vitro and their ability to be resorbed by osteoclasts in vivo. Both the sintered carbonate apatite and the bone apatite dissolved to an appreciable extent. Their solution compositions changed in an almost identical manner until toward the end of the reaction. The solution compositions for sintered carbonate apatite at 30 s was comparable with that for sintered hydroxyapatite at 3.8 days with respect to the degree of supersaturation, indicating that the former specimen is much more soluble than the latter specimen. Osteoclasts which were obtained from the long bones of 1-day-old neonatal rabbits resorbed bone and sintered carbonate apatite, but not sintered hydroxyapatite. These findings suggest that sintered carbonate apatites, which have characteristics that can be favorably compared with those of bone, especially with respect to its reactivity to acid media, would be useful as bioresorbable bone substitutes.

Bone apatite contains carbonate and is therefore not pure hydroxyapatite. We have successfully developed sintered carbonate apatite (CA) with a concentration of carbonate of 6 weight% and have evaluated its osteoconductive and bioresorption characteristics. Cylindrical porous sintered CA and sintered hydroxyapatite (HA) measuring 4 x 4 mm with a porosity of 20% were implanted into surgically-created bone defects in the knees of rabbits. The animals were killed after 1, 3, 6 and 12 months. The defects were evaluated by microfocus CT and histology. Bone growth into and around both materials increased. Newly-formed bone was placed in direct contact with both. Osteoclast-like cells resorbed only CA, and were coupled with osteoblasts. The porosity of sintered CA increased, indicating bioresorption, whereas that of sintered HA did not increase. Our findings indicate that sintered CA may be useful as a bioresorbable bone substitute.

No abstract

An apatite-collagen complex was prepared in calcium beta-glycerophosphate solutions at pH 9.0 and 37 degrees C with the purpose of developing new bone substitutes that more closely resemble bone than currently available materials. Reconstituted type I collagen as well as sheet collagen were crosslinked in the presence of alkaline phosphatase and egg-yolk phosvitin. The crosslinked collagens were immersed in daily-renewed calcium beta-glycerophosphate solutions for 2 and 4 weeks to induce the deposition of apatite on the collagen fibers. After 2 weeks of reaction, for example, apatites deposited approximately two times the crosslinked collagen in weight. With reconstituted collagen, the complex showed some elasticity but no apatite was visually observed to detach under deformation with fingers and forceps. The complex, moreover, did not disintegrate when immersed in saline or animal blood. Nevertheless, the complex resorbed with no evidence of cytotoxicity when implanted in muscle tissues. These findings suggest that the apatite-collagen complex prepared would be useful as bone substitutes, especially for periodontal osseous lesion repair and alveolar ridge augmentation.