Advance Care Planning in Asia: A Systematic Narrative Review of Healthcare Professionals’ Knowledge, Attitude, and Experience

Abstract

Objective: The value of advance care planning (ACP) for patients with life-limiting illnesses is widely recognized but Asian health care professionals' (HCPs') perspectives on ACP have received little systematic attention. We aim to synthesize evidence regarding Asian HCPs' knowledge of, attitudes toward, and experiences with ACP. Design: Systematic review with narrative synthesis and stepwise thematic analysis. Setting and Participants: HCPs in southern, eastern, and southeastern Asia. Methods: Studies from inception to September 2019 were identified from English-language searches of Embase, MEDLINE, Web of Science, and Google Scholar with reference-chaining and hand-searching. Two investigators independently screened and assessed the risk of bias in all original studies reporting HCPs' knowledge of, attitudes toward, and experiences with ACP, including their perspectives toward barriers and facilitators of ACP. Results: Fifty-one studies were included; 42 were quantitative, 43 had been conducted in high-income countries, and 36 were of good quality. Twenty-six studies operationalized ACP as the completion of an advance directive rather than a value-exploration process. Thirteen studies reported knowledge, 44 attitudes, 29 experiences, and 36 barriers and facilitators of ACP. Asian HCPs addressed the essential role of families in ACP. They acknowledge the importance of ACP but rarely engage the patient in it. They considered ACP difficult to initiate, partly because of their lack of knowledge and skills in ACP, personal uneasiness to conduct ACP, fear of conflicts with family members and their legal consequences, and the lack of a standard system for ACP. Most studies indicated HCPs' low engagement and late initiation of ACP. Conclusions and Implications: Despite acknowledging its importance, Asian HCPs felt that engaging in ACP is challenging. Capacity building for ACP in Asia should focus on culturally adapting ACP models concerning the essential role of the family in Asia, education for HCPs and the public, and providing institutional support for ACP.

Definition and recommended cultural considerations for advance care planning in Japan: A systematic review

“…A systematic review of the English-language articles on ACP in Asia including Japan, available on Embase, MEDLINE, Web of Science, and Google Scholar, has been reported. [ 13 ] The findings were integrated using a narrative synthesis because it has the distinction of being able to adopt a textual approach to the process of integration to “tell the story” of the findings from the studies it contains, as well as being able to involve the manipulation of statistical data. [ 14 ]…”

Asian patients’ perspectives on advance care planning: A mixed-method systematic review and conceptual framework

“…4,5 In our systematic review of Asian healthcare professionals’ perspectives on advance care planning, we found that professionals regard families as playing the leading role in it. 6 However, we also observed that these professionals rarely engage patients in advance care planning, even when the patients retain their decision-making capacity. Among the reasons for not engaging patients was healthcare professionals’ concern about patients’ lack of readiness to engage in advance care planning.…”

The Revised Medical Care Act is associated with a decrease in hospital death for the total Japanese older adult population regardless of dementia status: An interrupted time series analysis

“…For persons with dementia, the long trajectory towards the end of life encompasses complex care needs that require continuity and coordination of care across health and social care services. Therefore, we recommend policy that enables proactive end-of-life care planning that is integrated into health and social care reforms [ 41 ].…”