This paper questions one of the fundamental assumptions made in options pricing: that the daily returns of a stock are independent and identically distributed (IID). We apply an estimation procedure to years of daily return data for all stocks in the French CAC-40 index. We find six stocks whose log returns are best modeled by a first-order Markov chain, not an IID sequence. We further propose the Markov tree (MT) model, a modification of the standard binomial options pricing model, that takes into account this first-order Markov behavior. Empirical tests reveal that, for the six stocks found earlier, the MT model's option prices agree very closely with market prices.
IntroductionIn the Black-Scholes model for the price of a European option, one of the main assumptions is that the price of the underlying asset follows a geometric Brownian motion [8]. If S t is the underlying asset price at time t, one assumes dS t = μS t dt + σS t dW t , where μ and σ are constants and W t is a Brownian motion. For fixed t > 0, define X n = log(S (n+1)t /S nt ). Then