Associative Memory and Belief Formation

Abstract

This paper experimentally studies the role of associative memory for belief formation. Realworld information signals are often embedded in memorable contexts. Thus, today's news, and the contexts they are embedded in, may cue the selective retrieval of similar past news and hence contribute to the widely documented pattern of expectation overreaction. Based on a stylized version of models of associative memory in the literature, we develop a simple and tightly controlled experimental setup in which participants observe sequences of news about the stock market value of hypothetical companies. Here, identical types of news are associated with identical stories and images. In this setup, participants' expectations strongly overreact to recent news. We successfully verify the model's predictions about how the magnitude of overreaction should depend on the history of news. For example, once today's news are associated with the stories and images of previous opposite news, expectations systematically underreact. By exogenously manipulating the scope for imperfect and associative recall in our setup, we further provide direct causal evidence for the role of memory in belief formation and overreaction. Finally, we use our experimental data to estimate the model parameters that govern the strength of imperfect and associative recall over different time horizons. JEL-Codes: D010.

Are the Effects of Informational Interventions Driven by Salience?

“…9 Our findings relate to an active literature connecting salience to belief updating (e.g. Bordalo et al, 2012Bordalo et al, , 2019Enke et al, 2019;Hanna et al, 2014), extending that logic to the effects of informational interventions themselves. They also qualify the interpretation of previous results about the effects of informational interventions, particularly in the context of communication with parents (Bergman, 2017;Dizon-Ross, 2019;Jensen, 2010).…”

Emotional scene remembering: A combination of disturbing and facilitating effects of emotion?

“…Our findings confirm that the trade-off effect was restricted to high-complexity conditions since no difference between neutral and focal conditions were reported in the low-complexity condition. High-complexity conditions may have benefited from greater association ( Luck and Vogel, 1997 ; Rosen et al, 2018 ; Robin and Olsen, 2019 ; Enke et al, 2020 ) and/or greater elaboration ( Drivdahl et al, 2009 ; Migita et al, 2011 ; Nawa and Ando, 2019 ; Rubin et al, 2019 ). By revealing a modulation of the trade-off effect by picture complexity, our study suggests that such effects may be optimal in high-complexity conditions when memory is evaluated immediately.…”

Selective memory of a psychological agent

“…They incorporate the fact that such a process is imperfect and depends on the particular features of the current choices, leading to an asymmetric retrieval of past signals. Enke, Schwerter, and Zimmermann (2020) provide experimental evidence on the role of associative memory for beliefs formation. We do not consider associative memory but show that the imperfectness of the memorization process affects individuals' ability to exercise selective recall.…”