Tailoring high-performance aluminosilicates plays a key role in the efficient and clean production of high value chemicals. Recent works reveal that pentacoordinated Al (Al V) species can significantly enhance the Brønsted acidity of amorphous silica-alumina (ASA), compared to those typically dominated by tetracoordinated Al species. However, the controlled synthesis of Al V-rich ASAs is challenging. Employing xylene as the solvent in the flame-spray pyrolysis process we synthesized Al V-rich ASAs successfully. The high combustion enthalpy of xylene (36.9 kJ/ml) results in high flame temperature, promoting the formation and distribution of metastable Al V species in the silica network forming Brønsted acid sites. This provides a promising way for the controlled synthesis of Al V-rich ASAs with higher Brønsted acidity. As an example, the Al V-rich ASAs are shown to exhibit superior catalytic performance in the phenylglyoxal conversion to ethyl mandelate in ethanol compared to that achieved with other acid catalysts, providing an ethyl mandelate yield of 99.8 %.