Body-worn cameras ‘on the move’: exploring the contextual, technical and ethical challenges in policing practice

Abstract

The body-worn camera (BWC), an audio and video recording device, has been increasingly adopted by law enforcement across the globe. Drawing on a qualitative study, this paper will explore the use of these mobile devices in the UK and examine the challenges that have been faced during its implementation in two British police forces. In particular, we will discuss how these cameras move with the police officer's bodily movements (both intentionally and unintentionally) and are used for policing purposes in different settings (such as urban and rural contexts or different operational units). Based on a set of semistructured interviews with 26 police officers, this article will explore the contextual, technical and ethical challenges that hinder the use of BWCs in such settings. This study concludes that these practical and technosocial challenges are often interlinked. The context of use of these cameras and how they operate technically are connected, often raising significant ethical issues particularly for data management and storage. Ultimately it is argued that the operational perspective of the frontline officer is invaluable when designing and implementing technologies so they are policeman-proof.

Book Review

“…Based on qualitative work with police officers and other stakeholders (from activists to BWC developers), the author provides not only a very interesting theoretical and conceptual analysis but also an incredibly rich empirical account of how BWCs impact police daily work. This reinforces the importance of understanding police perspectives when implementing new technology such as BWCs (Miranda, 2022).…”

La tecnología al servicio de la vigilancia y de la defensa de la vida

“…Eso ha ocurrido con el empleo de cámaras, instaladas en drones y robots, así como en los uniformes de los policías. La cámara usada en el cuerpo (en inglés, BWC, por las iniciales de Body-Worn Camera), un dispositivo de grabación de audio y video, ha sido cada vez más adoptada por las autoridades policiales en todo el mundo (McKay & Lee, 2020;Miranda, 2021). Se trata de un incremento natural de las cámaras utilizadas por los patrulleros para investigación y almacenamiento de pruebas grabadas (Bloch, 2021).…”