Causal Linkage amongst Public Expenditure on Health, Health Status and Growth: New Empirical Evidence from Toda-Yamamoto Approach for Nigeria

Abstract

This study investigates the causal linkages amongst public expenditure on health, health status and economic growth in Nigeria using the Toda-Yamamoto technique. The choice of the Toda-Yamamoto approach is predicated on its simplicity and the ability to overcome the shortcomings inherent in the conventional causality procedures by producing more robust results through the estimation of the augmented VAR that guarantees the asymptotic distribution of the Wald statistic. To this end, the study collected annual time series data from the Central Bank of Nigeria’s Statistical bulletin and the World Development Indicator on public expenditure on health, life expectancy, infant mortality and real gross domestic product spanning 38 years from 1981 to 2018. The result of the study’s empirical analysis based on the co-integration test indicates that public health expenditure, health status and economic growth have long-run association. Further, the Toda-Yamamoto causality test result reveals the absence of causality between health expenditure and health status. Similarly, health status and economic growth are not causally interdependent. On the basis of the findings, the paper vehemently concludes that efforts to stimulate economic growth by targeting health outcomes improvement through public expenditure will be futile. As such, there is the need to develop better national health policy and programmes such as compulsory national health insurance that is capable of resolving the fundamental problems in the health sector. This would help integrate healthcare into the mainstream of the Nigerian economy.

The nexus between health expenditure, life expectancy, and economic growth: ARDL model analysis for Kenya

“…Olisakwe (2019) used the classical linear regression method over a period of 36 years and observed that increased government budgetary spending on the health sector inversely impacts economic growth in Nigeria. In the same line, Nwani and Kelikume (2019) also found similar findings as those by Olisakwe (2019). The study by Nwani and Kelikume (2019) employed the use of the Toda–Yamamoto analytic method to establish the causal connection between healthcare spending, health status, and GDP growth from 1981 to 2018.…”

“…In the same line, Nwani and Kelikume (2019) also found similar findings as those by Olisakwe (2019). The study by Nwani and Kelikume (2019) employed the use of the Toda-Yamamoto analytic method to establish the causal connection between healthcare spending, health status, and GDP growth from 1981 to 2018. They confirmed the existence of an inverse non-interdependent nexus relating to public healthcare spending and economic expansion.…”

Does life expectancy, death rate and public health expenditure matter in sustaining economic growth underCOVID‐19: Empirical evidence from Nigeria?

“…On contrary to this, Olisakwe (2019) argued that an increase in budgetary allocation for health has negative outcomes on economic growth this was proven by extracting data from 1981 to 2017 in Nigeria using a classical linear regression technique to conduct the investigation. Nwani and Kelikume (2019) deducted the same conclusion as Olisakwe (2019) 3 | DATA, MODEL, AND METHOD…”

Health Status, Government Health Expenditure and Economic Growth Nexus in India: A Toda–Yamamoto Causality Approach

“…The study revealed that health is a significant determinant of long-run economic growth in sub-Saharan African countries. Nwani and Kelikume (2019) investigated the linkage among public expenditure on health, health status and economic growth in Nigeria from 1981 to 2018. The results revealed that there existed a long-run association among public health expenditure, health status and economic growth.…”