Changes in teacher–student relationships

Abstract

Structured Abstract:Background: Although teacher-student relationships lie at the heart of students' schooling experience, fundamental questions regarding these relationships remain unanswered.Aims: This study investigates three related questions about these relationships: To what extent do they change from the beginning to the end of a school year? Are any emergent changes associated with shifts in students' academic or motivational outcomes? Are certain "upstream" factors associated with improvements or declines in teacher-student relationships?Sample: We investigate these questions with a sample of middle school students (N = 119) and their teachers (N = 30).Methods: Through a novel approach which accounts for both perspectives within teacherstudent relationships, we assess these relationships at the beginning and end of the school year.Using multi-level models, we examine how changes in these relationships are associated with changes in students' grades, homework completion rates, self-efficacy, and effort. In addition, we examine associations with two potential precursors to teacher-student relationships: students' accuracy in taking their teachers' perspective and their perceptions of similarity to their teachers. Results:We find that substantial changes occur in these relationships from the beginning to the end of the year; these changes are associated with shifts in important student outcomes; and changes in students' social perspective taking accuracy and perceived similarity to their teachers correspond with changes in teacher-student relationships. Conclusions:Given the malleability of teacher-student relationships and their importance for key achievement and motivational outcomes, we advocate for researchers to conduct field experiments to inform how to improve these critical relationships.Keywords: achievement; adolescence; effort; middle school; motivation; self-efficacy; similarity; social perspective taking; social processes / development; teacher-student relationships Running head: CHANGES IN TEACHER-STUDENT RELATIONSHIPS 3Changes in teacher-student relationships For 30 years, I've been covering school reform and we've basically reorganized the bureaucratic boxes -charters, private schools, vouchers -but we've had disappointing results year after year. And the fact is, people learn from people they love. And if you're not talking about the individual relationship between a teacher and a student, you're not talking about that reality. But that reality is expunged from our policy-making process.-David Brooks during his March 2011 TED talkAs David Brooks intimates, teacher-student relationships are among the most fundamental factors in successful schooling. What is especially striking about teacher-student relationships is not just that they matter, but that they appear consequential for such an extraordinary number and variety of academic and motivational outcomes for students (Juvonen, 2006).In this article, we extend the research on teacher-student relationships by examining how they change from...

Many ways to walk a mile in another’s moccasins: Type of social perspective taking and its effect on negotiation outcomes

“…Because perceived similarity plays such a central role in liking and relationships (Montoya, Horton, & Kirchner, 2008), we included two measures of similarity which were adapted from a similarity scale used in previous research (Gehlbach, Brinkworth, & Harris, 2012). Values-based similarity -the extent to which participants perceived that the ranger shared their values -was assessed through a 4-item scale ( = .87).…”

“…We measured the negotiation relationship through a self-report scale (6 items,  = .89) adapted from Gehlbach, Brinkworth, and Harris (2012).…”

“…This scale (6-items,  = .87) included items such as, "How confident were you that you could stick up for yourself during the negotiation?" These three measures were adapted from previous studies (Gehlbach & Barge, 2012;Gehlbach et al, 2008) for the current negotiation context.Because perceived similarity plays such a central role in liking and relationships (Montoya, Horton, & Kirchner, 2008), we included two measures of similarity which were adapted from a similarity scale used in previous research (Gehlbach, Brinkworth, & Harris, 2012). Values-based similarity -the extent to which participants perceived that the ranger shared their values -was assessed through a 4-item scale ( = .87).…”

Interpersonal Relationships in Education

“…Andrews: "Honestly, Bill, that child hasn't got a clue about my life, not a single clue" (Freaky Friday, 1976) In the movie Freaky Friday, Mrs. Andrews and her adolescent daughter Annabel are annoyed with each other. Because relationships are comprised of the two parties' actions, perceptions, and memories of those interactions (Gehlbach, Brinkworth, & Harris, 2012), improved relationships are essentially a subjective perception. They soon get their wishes.…”

Symbiotic Harmony: The Realistic Way to Develop Teacher-Student Relationship in University

“…It can be seen that the effective care is not unidirectional, which not only depends on the people who gives the care, but also hinges on the feedback of the people who is cared. Therefore, some efforts should be paid to the establishment of care relationship between teachers and students [11]. When the teachers care about students but the latter do not feel the care from the former, the care in this moment is no value.…”