Co-movements and diversification opportunities among Dow Jones Islamic indexes

Abstract

Purpose This paper aims to analyse the opportunity of an exclusive investment in the DJ Islamic indexes. The objective is to characterize the links between MENA region index with seven DJ Islamic indexes. Design/methodology/approach A co-movement analysis was conducted to assess whether there is a safe investment during crisis. The VECM verifies the existence of a long run association. The MGARCH-DCC characterizes the dynamic links. The wavelet coherence detects a correlation in a time-frequency domain, which is relevant to set up a diversification strategy based on investment horizons. Findings Despite the existence of a long run association between the Islamic indexes, diversification opportunities are present. The MGARCH-DCC results recommend including the USA, Canada and Emerging Markets indexes with the Mena index to get diversification benefits. The Wavelet coherence confirms these results for 0 to 16 days holding period and more than six-months’ investment horizons. Hence, MENA portfolio managers should not invest in Europe, UK and Emerging Markets indexes. Research limitations/implications This study focused only on the bivariate correlation analysis without taking into consideration multivariate relationships. Future research should use multiple wavelet coherence and explore S&P Shariah indexes. Practical implications This work is important for investors searching for assets governed by sharia rules, who reject resorting to conventional markets, and policy makers dealing with coordination costs. They would be able to formulate strategies based on the different indexes’ relationships. Originality/value This paper enriches the limited stream of literature focusing only on Islamic indexes. Due to the important development of Islamic Finance in each MENA country, the authors shed the light on this Region’s index.

Dow Jones Islamic Index firms: how profitable are they?

“…The literature also sheds some light on whether investing in Islamic equity funds can provide additional diversification benefits to conventional portfolios. Again, overall, the findings do not represent a consensus on this topic: some studies support the notion that investing in Islamic equity funds serves as an effective risk diversification strategy vis-à-vis investments in mainstream equity funds (Antar and Alahouel, 2019; Balcılar et al , 2015; Saiti et al ,2014). In other studies, researchers found that Islamic and conventional equity funds are strongly correlated (El Alaoui et al , 2015; Hammoudeh et al , 2014).…”

Portfolio Returns of Islamic Indices and Stock Prices in GCC Countries: Empirical Evidence From the ARDL Model

“…Due to the small and illiquid stock market and difficulties in generating foreign trading volumes, many countries create linkages with other Islamic exchange markets (Hassan & Yu, 2007). According to Antar and Alahouel (2020), there are some regional differences in stock market performance; thus, MENA investment portfolio managers should not invest in indices in Europe, the United Kingdom or emerging markets.…”

“…The measurement and selection of financial products should be consistent with Shariah criteria to avoid a conflict with the essence of Islam, which might create an obstacle in the development and growth of Islamic finance (Antar & Alahouel, 2020; Hakim & Rashidian, 2000). Financial products are evaluated through the Shariah Supervisory Board in accordance with Islamic Shariah, and products that do not conform to Shariah principles are excluded (Mansor & Bhatti, 2011).…”

Impact of Brexit on Islamic stock markets: employing MGARCH-DCC and wavelet correlation analysis

“…To explain how diversification diminishes risk, supposing the covariance is less than one (invariable true) will lead to a standard deviation less than the weighted average of the standard deviation of the expected returns of the securities. There have been numerous research studies conducted subsequent to these studies, which empirically test the covariance of asset returns amongst the stock market to explain portfolio diversification opportunities (Antar and Alahouel, 2020;Buriev et al, 2018;Saiti et al, 2014Saiti et al, , 2020. If there is a high correlation amongst the asset returns, it will decrease the whip hand of diversified investment portfolios (Xiao and Dhesi, 2010).…”