Combining proximate with online learning in real-time: ambidextrous teaching and pathways towards inclusion during COVID-19 restrictions and beyond

Abstract

COVID-19 forced universities to engage in rapid improvisation and adoption of online learning and teaching. This paper explores 'real-time blended' learning in which online students are taught simultaneously with students who are experiencing proximate learning.Two cliques could develop with those learning online becoming observers rather than participants in an active learning process. This paper is based on action-based research to develop an inclusive approach to simultaneous teaching of proximate and online students. This approach includes alterations in classroom layout, the equipment used, facilitating varying modes of social interaction and the role of communication. Effective teaching requires continual minor modifications to teaching design and delivery. This represents an ambidextrous approach to teaching in which teachers focus on the immediate co-creation of student experiences, but also identify cues which are used to adjust the ways in which they engage with a student cohort over the course of delivering a module. Module evaluation becomes an ongoing process in which alterations are made in real-time and to subsequent learning encounters with students. The paper evaluates student performance and concludes that the approach went some way towards ensuring equality of the student experience between those learning online and those proximate with the lecturer.

Moving Forward After COVID-19: New Directions for Teaching and Course Design in Higher Education

“…They encourage students to become creators and disseminators of knowledge (Loya, 2021). An inclusive-design approach to education is also based on the involvement of students and their experience in the co-creation process (Thomas & Bryson, 2021). According to Røe et al (2022), "student centredness is a multidimensional concept that encompasses the involvement of students in course decisions (including the selection of content and assessments), in the development of learning skills, and in shaping the [higher education] teacher's role" (p. 2).…”

“…Students must "feel appreciated, confident, called upon or brought into the course." The notion of empowerment is echoed in the literature, especially when it comes to active participation as noted by Thomas and Bryson (2021), and with student-centred education as noted by Røe et al (2022).…”

STEM learning during the COVID-19 pandemic in Qatar: Secondary school students’ and teachers’ perspectives

“…Following COVID-19, most teaching has switched from face-to-face to screen-to-face practices (Thomas & Bryson, 2021). Students engaged in studying STEM subjects found themselves in a very precarious position.…”

Assessing the Effectiveness of Geography-based Online Learning During the Covid-19 Pandemic in Higher Education

“…The novelty of this research was to provide information related to learning geography in higher education based on the location of different students, either in villages or cities. The two locations have different geographical characteristics that affect the quality of learning (Thomas & Bryson, 2021). Therefore, in a scenario where face-to-face learning is not implemented, online-based learning is needed using both the web and digital applications (Bryson & Andres, 2020;Holloway et al, 2021).…”