Conceptual Organization is Revealed by Consumer Activity Patterns

Abstract

Meaning may arise from an element's role or interactions within a larger system. For example, hitting nails is more central to people's concept of a hammer than its particular material composition or other intrinsic features. Likewise, the importance of a web page may result from its links with other pages rather than solely from its content. One example of meaning arising from extrinsic relationships are approaches that extract the meaning of word concepts from co-occurrence patterns in large, text corpora. The success of these methods suggest that human activity patterns may reveal conceptual organization. However, texts do not directly reflect human activity, but instead serve a communicative function and are usually highly curated or edited to suit an audience. Here, we apply methods devised for text to a data source that directly reflects thousands of individuals' activity patterns, namely supermarket purchases. Using product co-occurrence data from nearly 1.3m shopping baskets, we trained a topic model to learn 25 high-level concepts (or topics). These topics were found to be comprehensible and coherent by both retail experts and consumers. Topics ranged from specific (e.g., ingredients for a stir-fry) to general (e.g., cooking from scratch). Topics tended to be goal-directed and situational, consistent with the notion that human conceptual knowledge is tailored to support action. Individual differences in the topics sampled predicted basic demographic characteristics. These results suggest that human activity patterns reveal conceptual organization and may give rise to it. cognition | computational social science | big data | machine learning | decision making

Investigating the origin and consequences of endogenous default options in repeated economic choices

“…This specification states that, assuming that two processes can execute the decision in a strictly independent manner with distinct RT distributions, the observed distribution of RTs is a mixture of those distributions, and all mixture proportions should share a common density point. Consistent with prior work in perceptual decision-making [63,64], we found no evidence for a fixed-point under the different levels of time pressure. Note, however, that the fixed-point test is a conservative test, with conservative assumptions: if, in addition to the change in the mixture proportion, time pressure affects some other aspect of the data then the fixed-point property may not apply, even though the actual true generative process is a mixture of processes [35,36].…”

How Computational Modeling Can Force Theory Building in Psychological Science

“…Some believe the replication crisis is a measure of the scientific quality of a sub-field, and given that it has affected areas of psychology with less formal modeling, one possibility might be to ask these areas to model explicitly. By extension, modelers can begin to publish more in these areas (e.g., in consumer behaviour, see Hornsby, Evans, Riefer, Prior, & Love, 2019).…”

Multiscale Computation and Dynamic Attention in Biological and Artificial Intelligence

“…In widely reported behaviors in behavioral economics, people’s choices tend to show temporal dependencies across multiple time-scales [ 49 ]. While these behaviors have been previously regarded merely as “anomalies” [ 50 , 51 ], it may be more natural to think that multiscale processing has evolutionary significance beyond the narrowly-defined rational theories of behavior that assume an independence between trials that is unlikely in the real world [ 52 , 53 , 54 , 55 ].…”