Contributions of moral education lectures and moral discussion in Hong Kong secondary schools

Abstract

Moral education in the traditional form of classroom didactic lectures in secondary schools has been prevailing in Hong Kong since the initiation of moral education in the 1980s. However, such a traditional form has not received credit from research in the West. Instead, discussion of moral issues would be a more effective way of moral education than would didactic lectures. Because of the differential ways of moral education in Hong Kong, findings from other places can be subject to a test in Hong Kong. As such, this study employed panel data from 19,069 secondary school students in Hong Kong to analyze the impacts of moral education on moral commitment to sustain societal interests. Findings indicated a weak contribution of moral discussion and an even weaker contribution of moral education lectures to moral commitment. These findings therefore echo those in other places and suggest that real-life moral education contributes in the expected way, albeit weakly.

Possible competences to be aimed at in ethics education – Ethical competences highlighted in educational research journals

“…The importance of developing less egocentric perspectives, highlighting the common and societal good as well as respect for the other, is stressed (e.g. Cheung and Lee 2010). Several studies are reported that have the purpose of evaluating whether education and training can develop such preferences (e.g.…”

“…Several studies are reported that have the purpose of evaluating whether education and training can develop such preferences (e.g. Allen et al 2011;Cheung and Lee 2010). An interesting theme that is implied in several articles concerns how much individuals can be held responsible, given how influenced they are by their contexts and the hegemonic discourses of these contexts (e.g.…”

Applying Participatory Observation in Islamic Education to Improve Students’ Character

“…The use of moral discussion and moral lecture method contributed weakly on moral commitment of more than 1900 secondary students. The research also suggested importance of real-life moral education (Cheung & Lee, 2010).…”

Vietnamese Students' Perceptions of Moral Values: An Assessment by Students at An Giang University

“…There should be a harmonious combination between the content and the method of moral teaching [3]. Another concern is the learning method, the self-study method so that learners can learn for life, it is identified as an important factor in the process of educating students [1].…”

“…Universities should create a democratic, healthy and friendly environment, and implement cultural codes of conduct in schools. Education and training institutions should arrange and use playgrounds, training grounds, and upgrade facilities to serve the activities of hobby clubs in order to meet the demand for healthy entertainment and recreation [4]. If the issues just discussed are solved well, it will be directly proportional to the improvement of the quality of education, and the quality of traditional moral education will be more effective.…”