Controlling Mortality Caused by External Columnaris in Largemouth Bass and Bluegill with Chloramine‐T or Hydrogen Peroxide

Abstract

Columnaris (causative agent, Flavobacterium columnare) is a widespread fish disease of concern among fish culturists in the USA. If left untreated, an entire population of fish may become infected, and morbidity and mortality may reach high levels. In virtually all instances, columnaris outbreaks require intervention to prevent significant losses. A number of sanitizing agents, most notably chloramine‐T (CLT) and hydrogen peroxide (HP), have been used to control mortality associated with a variety of bacterial pathogens causing external infections. However, the majority of trials conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of these chemicals, thereby gaining U.S. Food and Drug Administration approval for their use in treating fish infected with columnaris, have been conducted on salmonids. Accordingly, we conducted seven experiments to evaluate the effectiveness of CLT or HP to control mortality associated with external columnaris in Florida Largemouth Bass Micropterus salmoides floridanus and Bluegill Lepomis macrochirus. Treatment with CLT or HP significantly reduced cumulative mortality in five of the seven experiments. Cumulative mortality was strongly correlated to pretreatment mortality in treated and control tanks in the five Largemouth Bass experiments, suggesting that intervention at later stages of columnaris progression may result in less favorable outcomes. Odds ratios calculated for individual experiments indicated varying degrees of success in controlling mortality; however, meta‐analysis of all experiments indicated treatment with either CLT or HP significantly increased probability of survival, regardless of fish species or test article. These results demonstrate that both chemicals can be effective in controlling mortality associated with external columnaris in Largemouth Bass and Bluegills and that timely treatment of fish will likely result in lower overall mortality.

Kaolinitic clay protects against Flavobacterium columnare infection in channel catfish Ictalurus punctatus (Rafinesque)

“…; Bowker et al . ). Limitations such as regulatory issues, water quality/chemistry, safety/toxicity and the challenge models and target species by which these compounds were tested for effectiveness may impede their use in production settings.…”

Evaluation of Glutaraldehyde, Chloramine-T, Bronopol, Incimaxx Aquatic® and Hydrogen Peroxide as Biocides against Flavobacterium psychrophilum for Sanitization of Rainbow Trout Eyed Eggs

“…Although, it is used in aquaculture against bacterial and protozoal infections eliciting little or no response of oxidative stress biomarkers from Oncorhynchus mykiss when exposed to chloramine-T 10 ppm for 20 min (3 days; 3 expositions per day; [27]), it is not yet approved by the U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for use on fish [28]. Previously, chloramine-T 15 ppm was found to be effective within 10 min against some Aeromonas spp.…”

Mythbusters: What's Real and What's Not When It Comes to Fish Drugs

“…Aquaculturists can little afford to incur additional costs of rearing fish, so administering fish drugs when they are not needed is considered a waste of money, particularly when the evidence of antibiotic-related growth promotion in fish is sparse and equivocal (He et al 2014). For example, at current prices it would cost US$35 to treat a relatively small cement raceway (18.3 m × 1.8 m with a water depth of 0.9 m) for 60 min/d for 3 d with 20 mg/L HALAMID Aqua (chloramine-T) and $73 to administer the same treatment with 50 mg/L 35% PEROX-AID (hydrogen peroxide; Bowker et al 2013). Another example is that there is a cost increase of $7.50-$30 per 50 lb bag of feed to top-coat the feed with one of the FDA-approved antibiotics (at current prices).…”