Coping with stress in medical students: results of a randomized controlled trial using a mindfulness-based stress prevention training (MediMind) in Germany

Abstract

BackgroundHigh prevalence rates of psychological distress in medical training and later professional life indicate a need for prevention. Different types of intervention were shown to have good effects, but little is known about the relative efficacy of different types of stress management interventions, and methodological limitations have been reported. In order to overcome some of these limitations, the present study aimed at evaluating the effect of a specifically developed mindfulness-based stress prevention training for medical students (MediMind) on measures of distress, coping and psychological morbidity.MethodsWe report on a prospective randomized controlled trial with three study conditions: experimental treatment (MediMind), standard treatment (Autogenic Training) and a control group without treatment. The sample consisted of medical or dental students in the second or eighth semester. They completed self-report questionnaires at baseline, after the training and at one year follow-up. Distress (Trier Inventory for the Assessment of Chronic Stress, TICS) was assessed as the primary outcome and coping (Brief COPE) as a co-primary outcome. Effects on the psychological morbidity (Brief Symptom Inventory, BSI) as a secondary outcome were expected one year after the trainings.ResultsInitially, N = 183 students were randomly allocated to the study groups. At one year follow-up N = 80 could be included into the per-protocol analysis: MediMind (n =31), Autogenic Training (n = 32) and control group (n = 17). A selective drop-out for students who suffered more often from psychological symptoms was detected (p = .020). MANCOVA’s on TICS and Brief COPE revealed no significant interaction effects. On the BSI, a significant overall interaction effect became apparent (p = .002, η2partial = .382), but post hoc analyses were not significant. Means of the Global Severity Index (BSI) indicated that MediMind may contribute to a decrease in psychological morbidity.ConclusionDue to the high and selective dropout rates, the results cannot be generalized and further research is necessary. Since the participation rate of the trainings was high, a need for further prevention programs is indicated. The study gives important suggestions on further implementation and evaluation of stress prevention in medical schools.Trial registrationThis trial is recorded at German Clinical Trials Register under the number DRKS00005354 (08.11.2013).

Anxiety and Sleep Quality in Dental Students at a Private Brazilian University

“…Actions aimed at promoting health in the academic environment are desirable, as is identifying factors that might adversely affect it 50) . Some earlier studies reported that training in stress prevention was associated with a reduction in stress among undergraduate students 25,30,51) . Such strategies should be incorporated into health profession training programs, and include mindfulness-based intervention, relaxation, and meditation 30,49) .…”

Psychiatric and psychological follow-up of undergraduate and postgraduate medical students: Prevalence and associated factors. Results from the national BOURBON study

“…Recent studies have suggested that some other interventions may be useful in medical students experiencing stress including non-pharmacological intervention (mindfulness-based stress reduction (Kuhlmann et al, 2016), self-hypnosis, feedback on various health habits, educational discussion (Shiralkar et al, 2013)), complementary agents intervention (omega 3 (Kiecolt-Glaser et al, 2011) and probiotics (Kato-Kataoka et al, 2016)) and organizational interventions (changes in the length and type of curriculum, and changes in the grading system (Shiralkar et al, 2013)). Recent meta-analyses on interventions to reduce stress in physicians have suggested that organizational interventions may be more efficient that individualbased ones (Brand et al, 2017;Busireddy et al, 2017;Panagioti et al, 2017).…”

Self‐reported psychological problems amongst undergraduate dental students: A pilot study in seven European countries

“…Some work has been done to improve dental students' learning environment, like teaching stress management in the UK and mindfulness in Germany . Studies from India and Turkey suggested that spiritual health/religion may increase students' coping strategies .…”