Costs and benefits of using cross-docking in the retail supply chain

Abstract

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate the costs/benefits of implementing the cross-docking strategy in a retail supply chain context using a cost model. In particular, the effects of using different typologies of cross-docking compared to traditional warehousing are investigated, taking into consideration an actual case study of a fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) company and a major French retailer. Design/methodology/approach The research is based on a case study of an FMCG company and a major French retailer. The case study is used to develop a cost model and to identify the main cost parameters impacted by implementing the cross-docking strategy. Based on the cost model, a comparison of the main cost factors characterizing four different configurations is made. The configurations studied are, the traditional warehousing strategy (AS-IS configuration, the reference configuration for comparison), where both retailers and suppliers keep inventory in their warehouses; the cross-docking pick-by-line strategy, where inventory is removed from the retailer warehouse and the allocation and sorting are performed at the retailer distribution centre (DC) level (TO-BE1 configuration); the cross-docking pick-by-store strategy, where the allocation and sorting are done at the supplier DC level (TO-BE2 configuration); and finally a combination of cross-docking pick-by-line strategy and traditional warehousing strategy (TO-BE3 configuration). Findings The case study provides three main observations. First, compared to traditional warehousing, cross-docking with sorting and allocation done at the supplier level increases the entire supply chain cost by 5.3 per cent. Second, cross-docking with allocation and sorting of the products done at the retailer level is more economical than traditional warehousing: a 1 per cent reduction of the cost. Third, combining cross-docking and traditional warehousing reduces the supply chain cost by 6.4 per cent. Research limitations/implications A quantitative case study may not be highly generalisable; however, the findings form a foundation for further understanding of the reconfiguration of a retail supply chain. Originality/value This paper fills a gap by proposing a cost analysis based on a real case study and by investigating the costs and benefits of implementing different configurations in the retail supply chain context. Furthermore, the cost model may be used to help managers choose the right distribution strategy for their supply chain.

Modeling a Logistics Hub Using the Digital Footprint Method—The Implication for Open Innovation Engineering

“…In addition, manufacturers also benefit, since the JIT technology can be implemented in both directions of flows. Accordingly, new cross-docking and pick-by-line technologies are being introduced at DC [23]. The criteria for economic efficiency [24] when maximizing the 3PL operator's profit can be the minimization of costs for the DC scale and the balance between possible costs (for example, for the factors of demurrage and detention or for contractual penalties for non-delivery or late shipment) [25].…”

Cross-Docking: A Systematic Literature Review

“…Some store chains like grocery chains, bring the products into one location and re-split them to multiple locations at different stores. A study of cross-docking in the retail sector [70] examined the costs/benefits of implementing the cross-docking strategy in a major French retail supply chain, in particular, fast-moving consumer goods.…”

Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG) Market in Romania. Features and Trends

“…Based on a survey conducted among young people, the authors pointed out that the attempt to introduce self-service technology in retail is not accepted by Croatian consumers and that they consider it as an auxiliary register, mainly due to frequent technical failures, requiring further measures to improve computer systems. The optimization of storage systems in retail networks in France, based on the application of the cross-docking strategy, was analysed by Benrqya (2019). The author demonstrated that significant reductions in storage costs can be achieved at the supermarket level, by combining cross-docking methods with traditional storage systems.…”