Cultural influences on social feedback processing of character traits

Abstract

Cultural differences are generally explained by how people see themselves in relation to social interaction partners. While Western culture emphasizes independence, East Asian culture emphasizes interdependence. Despite this focus on social interactions, it remains elusive how people from different cultures process feedback on their own (and on others') character traits. Here, participants of either German or Chinese origin engaged in a face-to-face interaction. Consequently, they updated their self- and other-ratings of 80 character traits (e.g., polite, pedantic) after receiving feedback from their interaction partners. To exclude potential confounds, we obtained data from German and Chinese participants in Berlin [functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI)] and in Beijing (behavior). We tested cultural influences on social conformity, positivity biases, and self-related neural activity. First, Chinese conformed more to social feedback than Germans (i.e., Chinese updated their trait ratings more). Second, regardless of culture, participants processed self- and other-related feedback in a positively biased way (i.e., they updated more toward desirable than toward undesirable feedback). Third, changes in self-related medial prefrontal cortex activity were greater in Germans than in Chinese during feedback processing. By investigating conformity, positivity biases, and self-related activity in relation to feedback obtained in a real-life interaction, we provide an essential step toward a unifying framework for understanding the diversity of human culture.

Neural correlates of the self-reference effect: evidence from evaluation and recognition processes

“…Additionally, one factor that could influence our results is culture. Previous studies indicated that there were cultural differences, not only behavioral but also neural, in self-referential processing (Zhu et al, 2007 ; Korn et al, 2014 ; Ma et al, 2014 ). SRE is known to be relatively robust across cultures, but it is possible to show different results between participants from different cultural backgrounds (for example, Westerner vs. East Asian) when they perform referential and recognition tasks, especially in the comparison between self and close-other, for example, a parent or friend.…”

Beauty is in the belief of the beholder: cognitive influences on the neural response to facial attractiveness

“…An interesting question for future research is whether people tend to weigh negative vs positive social information differently in appraisals of facial beauty. In a recent fMRI study, Korn et al (2014) offered evidence that, across cultures, evaluations of character traits are more amenable to positive ( vs negative) social information. Such findings support the possibility that positive vs negative social information is accorded varying levels of significance in shaping one’s judgments of attractiveness.…”

Informational and Normative Influences in Conformity from a Neurocomputational Perspective

“…Note, we distinguish between the observed behaviour (conformity) and whether this behaviour was elicited by the available information (adaptive response) or a general norm whereby following the majority is the socially desirable behaviour. There are clear cultural differences in the strength of these majority influences [53,54].…”