Darwin’s bureaucrat

Abstract

The study of bureaucratic behavior—focusing on control, decision-making, and institutional arrangements—has historically leaned heavily on theories of rational choice and bounded rationality. Notably absent from this research, however, is attention to the growing literature on biological and especially evolutionary human behavior. This article addresses this gap by closely examining the extant economic and psychological frameworks—which we refer to as “Adam Smith’s bureaucrat” and “Herbert Simon’s bureaucrat”—for their shortcomings in terms of explanatory and predictive theory, and by positing a different framework, which we call “Charles Darwin’s bureaucrat.” This model incorporates new insights from an expanding multidisciplinary research framework and has the potential to address some of the long-noted weaknesses of classic theories of bureaucratic behavior.

Exploring the foundational origins of public service motivation through the lens of behavioral genetics

“…Second, an evolutionary basis of bureaucratic behavior has recently been reintroduced to the literature, therefore serving as a promising starting point for further theorizing (Smith & Renfro, 2019).…”

“…First, evolutionary theories are now being explored in relation to “other‐regarding” phenomena (Nowak, 2006; Van Vugt & Schaller, 2008). Second, an evolutionary basis of bureaucratic behavior has recently been reintroduced to the literature, therefore serving as a promising starting point for further theorizing (Smith & Renfro, 2019).…”