Designing an Adaptive Interface: Using Eye Tracking to Classify How Information Usage Changes Over Time in Partially Automated Vehicles

Abstract

While partially automated vehicles can provide a range of benefits, they also bring about new Human Machine Interface (HMI) challenges around ensuring the driver remains alert and is able to take control of the vehicle when required. While humans are poor monitors of automated processes, specifically during 'steady state' operation, presenting the appropriate information to the driver can help. But to date, interfaces of partially automated vehicles have shown evidence of causing cognitive overload. Adaptive HMIs that automatically change the information presented (for example, based on workload, time or physiologically), have been previously proposed as a solution, but little is known about how information should adapt during steady-state driving. This study aimed to classify information usage based on driver experience to inform the design of a future adaptive HMI in partially automated vehicles. The unique feature of this study over existing literature is that each participant attended for five consecutive days; enabling a first look at how information usage changes with increasing familiarity and providing a methodological contribution to future HMI user trial study design. Seventeen participants experienced a steady-state automated driving simulation for twenty-six minutes per day in a driving simulator, replicating a regularly driven route, such as a work commute. Nine information icons, representative of future partially automated vehicle HMIs, were displayed on a tablet and eye tracking was used to record the information that the participants fixated on. The results found that information usage did change with increased exposure, with significant differences in what information participants looked at between the first and last trial days. With increasing experience, participants tended to view information as confirming technical competence rather than the future state of the vehicle. On this basis, interface design recommendations are made, particularly around the design of adaptive interfaces for future partially automated vehicles. INDEX TERMS Intelligent vehicles, autonomous vehicles, interface, eye tracking, information requirements, HMI.

The influence of system transparency on trust: Evaluating interfaces in a highly automated vehicle

“…Interface designers have also to find a fine balance between what to present to increase trust without overloading users, taking in consideration the level of automation of the vehicle. The provision of configurable or adaptive screens can facilitate the adjustment of its contents according to immediate needs (Ulahannan et al, 2020). For high or full autonomy, occupants may not need or want system transparency information at all.…”

“…Future studies could make use of longitudinal methods to evaluate the evolution of user experience and trust and formulate definite recommendations for the design of system transparency interfaces by continuously optimising and integrating successful or preferred features from other concept designs. It is well accepted that users form and modify their judgments about a system over time (Venkatesh et al, 2010), and thus research in human-computer interaction should give more attention to the study of changes over time (Oliveira et al, 2019a;Ulahannan et al, 2020).…”

Ergonomic Guidelines of Head-Up Display User Interface during Semi-Automated Driving

“…Depending on the preference of the driver's level of information acceptance, the information displayed in the HUD may receive a negative response. To address this, an adaptable interface design should be introduced to take into account the factors that can inspire user experience by considering those who prefer low information acceptance [57,58]. The adaptable interface design can be appropriately considered for intuitiveness and safety, which familiarizes the driver with the context for vehicle information.…”

Design and Implementation of Inverse Kinematics and Motion Monitoring System for 6DoF Platform

“…Simulators continue to progress toward high performance, high fidelity, and complex, realistic scenes [1]. A motion platform with six degrees of freedom (DoF) simulates the dynamic motion of several vehicles to be perceived by passengers.…”

“…The software offers functions such as sampling settings, impulse response display, real-time display of measured values, and log file reading and sending. To the best of our knowledge, the ideas we mention have not been presented in previously published papers [1][2][3][4][5][6][7][8][9][10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18]. As a result, this paper presents some new ideas on the implementation of motion control systems, including an adjustable speed control system and a middle-distance stroke control system.…”