“…(21) and (22), the soil erodibility and critical shear stress for sheet erosion initiating are 0.0051 s/m and 0.02 Pa and for rill erosion initiating are 0.0027 s/m and 10.41 Pa, respectively, which means that as soil erosion by runoff continued to occur and soil erosion pattern shifted from sheet erosion to rill erosion, soil erodibility decreased but critical shear stress increased. The fitted equations are consistent with the results from previous researches conducted for natural/disturbed agricultural and road surface soils (Cao et al, 2009;Cochrane and Flanagan, 1997;He et al, 2003;Lei and Yang, 2004;Nearing et al, 1999;Zhang et al, 2003), with the exception of significant differences in soil erodibility and critical shear stress. The values of soil erodibility reported in some current studies ranged from 8.18 × 10 − 4 to 8.4 × 10 −3 s/m Zhang et al, 2003;Zhang and Zhang, 2000), which are much less than the soil erodibility for a road surface soil with slope gradients ranged from 8.8% to 46.6% (Cao et al, 2009) and an intact agricultural soil with slope gradients ranged from 3.5% to 46.6% .…”