Disparities in Physicians' Interpretations of Heart Disease Symptoms by Patient Gender: Results of a Video Vignette Factorial Experiment

Abstract

Background: Previous studies have documented the underdiagnosis of coronary heart disease (CHD) in women, but less is known about which alternate diagnoses take precedence and whether additional patient factors modify possible gender bias. Objective: To measure gender variation in clinical decision making, including (1) the number, types, and certainty levels of diagnoses considered and (2) how diagnoses vary according to patient characteristics, when patients have identical symptoms of CHD. Methods: This was a factorial experiment presenting videotaped CHD symptoms, systematically altering patient gender, age, socioeconomic status (SES) and race, and physician gender and level of experience. The primary end point was physicians' most certain diagnosis. Results: Physicians (n ¼ 128) mentioned five diagnoses on average, most commonly heart, gastrointestinal, and mental health conditions. Physicians were significantly less certain of the underlying cause of symptoms among female patients regardless of age ( p ¼ 0.006), but only among middle-aged women were they significantly less certain of the CHD diagnosis ( p < 0.001). Among middle-aged women, 31.3% received a mental health condition as the most certain diagnosis, compared with 15.6% of their male counterparts ( p ¼ 0.03). An interaction effect showed that females with high SES were most likely to receive a mental health diagnosis as the most certain ( p ¼ 0.006). Conclusions: Middle-aged female patients were diagnosed with the least confidence, whether for CHD or non-CHD conditions, indicating that their gender and age combination misled physicians, particularly toward mental health alternative diagnoses. Physicians should be aware of the potential for psychological symptoms to erroneously take a central role in the diagnosis of younger women.

Preventing and Experiencing Ischemic Heart Disease as a Woman: State of the Science

“…220–222 This uncertainty often results in less aggressive and/or less timely treatment for women with possible IHD. In fact, research shows that women are consistently treated less intensely than men before and after the diagnosis of IHD in the U.S. and other countries.…”

Implicit Gender Bias and the Use of Cardiovascular Tests Among Cardiologists

“…Our participants estimated the likelihood of obstructive CAD in hypothetical male and female patients similarly but felt less certain of these estimates for the female patient. Other studies have similarly shown that physician certainty of cardiac diagnoses varied by patient gender and influenced clinical decisions 58, 59. Consequently, efforts to reduce gender disparities in management may need to focus on increasing physician certainty of evaluating suspected CAD in female patients.…”

Gaps in Preparedness of Clergy and Healthcare Providers to Address Mental Health Needs of Returning Service Members

“…The use of a standardized vignette builds on our previous findings that this type of standardized stimuli can be used to differentiate between the assessments of participants from different disciplines (Gorrindo et al 2013). Other previous research has also shown that standardized vignettes can successfully be used to elucidate discrepancies in symptom recognition and diagnosis for both physical and mental illnesses Maserejian et al 2009;McKinlay et al 2013;Welch et al 2012).…”