Distinguishing screening mechanisms with environment-dependent velocity statistics

Abstract

Context. Alternative theories of gravity typically invoke an environment-dependent screening mechanism to allow phenomenologically interesting deviations from general relativity (GR) to manifest on larger scales, while reducing to GR on small scales. The observation of the transition from screened to unscreened behavior would be compelling evidence for beyond-GR physics. Aims. We show that pairwise peculiar velocity statistics, in particular the relative radial velocity dispersion, σ , can be used to observe this transition when they are binned by some measure of halo environment. Methods. We established this by measuring the radial velocity dispersion between pairs of halos in N-body simulations for three f (R) gravity and four symmetron models. We developed an estimator involving only line-of-sight velocities to show that this quantity is observable, and binned the results in halo mass, ambient density, and the isolatedness of halos. Results. Ambient density is found to be the most relevant measure of environment; it is distinct from isolatedness, and correlates well with theoretical expectations for the symmetron model. By binning σ in ambient density, we find a strong environment-dependent signature for the symmetron models, with the velocities showing a clear transition from GR to non-GR behavior. No such transition is observed for f (R), as the relevant scales are deep in the unscreened regime. Conclusions. Observations of the relative radial velocity dispersion in forthcoming peculiar velocity surveys, if binned appropriately by environment, therefore offer a valuable way of detecting the screening signature of modified gravity.

Cosmology with Phase 1 of the Square Kilometre Array Red Book 2018: Technical specifications and performance forecasts

“…Peculiar velocity statistics are particularly sensitive to the growth rate of structure and so can be used as powerful probes of modified gravitational physics (e.g. Hellwing et al 2014;Koda et al 2014;Ivarsen et al 2016).…”

The slingshot effect as a probe of transverse motions of galaxies

“…If the modifications apply on galaxy scales, each galaxy can be more massive and more dense. If the modifications apply on megaparsec scales, galaxies will fall faster due to the fifth forces on large scales (Ivarsen et al 2016). Both of these effects would increase the expected sling-shot signal with respect to a similar scenario in ΛCDM, making it a possible probe for enhanced gravity over several different scales.…”

“…Several of the above problems can be partially solved if we consider data from the upcoming Square Kilometre Array (SKA) phase 2, expected to be online in 2030 (Bull 2016). SKA is a planned full-sky spectroscopic survey, and Norris et al (2014) suggest that it is expected to identify the position and redshift of all galaxies of the relevant magnitudes up to z = 0.05.…”

Fundamental physics with the Square Kilometre Array

“…SKA1 will be able to perform a wide, highly over-sampled TF peculiar velocity measurement at low redshift (cf., the sensitivity curves of Yahya et al 2015), potentially resulting in better constraints on the growth rate than achievable with RSDs. The peculiar velocity data would also be suitable for testing (environment-dependent) signatures of modified gravity due to screening, as discussed by Hellwing et al (2014) and Ivarsen et al (2016).…”