“…In this paper, the academic landscape system (Kajikawa et al, 2007;Innovation Policy Research Center, 2016) was adopted as a method of characterizing research in smart energy. This method has been applied previously to the characterization of sustainability (Kajikawa, 2008), its assessment methods (Kikuchi, 2014), energy security (Kiriyama and Kajikawa, 2014), and distributed energy sources (Kikuchi et al, 2016a). 7,468 papers were retrieved from a Web-based literature database, "Web of Science" (Thomson Reuters, 2016), which included "smart energy, " "smart community, " "smart grid, " "district heating, " "computable general equilibrium (CGE), " "MARKAL, " or "energy system simulation" in the abstract, title, or keywords, and clusters were created based on these citation networks.…”