Objective: To analyze and compare the preoperative factors that potentially influence the outcome of stapedotomy in our study group. Materials and Methods: 161 cases were enrolled. Clinical variables considered to influence functional results – air conduction (AC) and bone conduction (BC) pure-tone average (PTA), air-bone gaps (ABG), sensorineural hearing loss (SNHL), ABG gain and ΔSNHL – were gender, age, case type (unilateral vs. bilateral), ear side (right vs. left), pregnancy, vascular disease and family history of otosclerosis. The audiometric variables were preoperative AC- and BC-PTA, SNHL and ABG. Results: Univariate logistic regression analysis showed that the probability of obtaining a ≥10 dB gain is significantly affected by the following factors: age <50 years, AC-PTA ≥50 dB and preoperative ABG ≥30 dB. All the other factors included into the registration (gender, familiarity, side, bilateral vs. unilateral, pregnancy, vascular diseases and preoperative BC-PTA) were not found to significantly affect postoperative gain (p > 0.05). Nevertheless, multivariate logistic regression analysis maintained a statistically significant correlation only between gain ≥10 dB and both preoperative ABG ≥30 dB and age <50 years. Conclusions: The accurate knowledge of predictive factors is a valuable tool that permits the surgeon to plan surgery with a better case selection as well as assisting in counseling the patient with regard to the likelihood of success of the procedure.