Effect of anthropogenic light on bird movement, habitat selection, and distribution: a systematic map protocol

Abstract

Background: Anthropogenic light is known or suspected to exert profound effects on many taxa, including birds. Documentation of bird aggregation around artificial light at night, as well as observations of bird reactions to strobe lights and lasers, suggests that light may both attract and repel birds, although this assumption has yet to be tested. These effects may cause immediate changes to bird movement, habitat selection and settlement, and ultimately alter bird distribution at large spatial scales. Global increases in the extent of anthropogenic light contribute to interest by wildlife managers and the public in managing light to reduce harm to birds, but there are no evidence syntheses of the multiple ways light affects birds to guide this effort. Existing reviews usually emphasize either bird aggregation or deterrence and do so for a specific context, such as aggregation at communication towers and deterrence from airports. We outline a protocol for a systematic map that collects and organizes evidence from the many contexts in which anthropogenic light is reported to affect bird movement, habitat selection, or distribution. Our map will provide an objective synthesis of the evidence that identifies subtopics that may support systematic review and knowledge gaps that could direct future research questions. These products will substantially advance an understanding of both patterns and processes associated with the responses of birds to anthropogenic light. Methods: The protocol describes the steps taken to ensure the search for evidence is comprehensive, transparent and replicable. We will find relevant studies in the grey and peer-reviewed literature using publication databases, Google Scholar, stakeholder suggestions, and organizational websites. We will select studies for inclusion in the map by identification of relevant: (i) population including any species of bird; (ii) intervention or exposure to anthropogenic light; and (iii) outcomes including changes in bird movement, habitat occupancy, population density, or distribution. We will extract and organize metadata into a systematic map that can support subsequent search by interested individuals. The quantity of evidence on particular topics will be characterized through heat maps and narrative syntheses, but subsequent work will be needed to evaluate evidence validity.

A review of the effects of artificial light at night in urban areas on the ecosystem level and the remedial measures

“…They found that individuals spent significantly more time hiding in the shelter when subjected to ALAN than when exposed to control conditions. Also, Gavi and colleagues identified that the female seed predators flew away from the plants near the light source to lay eggs on plants either in darkness or exposed to low light intensity ( 83 ).…”

Captive diet does not influence exploration behavior upon reintroduction to the wild in a critically endangered amphibian

“…Shier and Owings, 2006;Vargas and Anderson, 1999;Beck et al, 2002;Richardson et al, 2019), there are numerous ways that behavioral research stands to aid conservation efforts. Most notably, behavioral research can help conservation managers to; (1) better understand how well animals acclimate to captive environments (Clubb & Mason, 2007;Yamanashi et al, 2016) (2) select optimal behavioral types and sex ratios for captive breeding and reintroduction (Robertson et al, 2006;Kelleher et al, 2018), (3) more effectively control invasive species (Hurley et al, 2015) and (4) predict individual and population level responses to agents of environmental change, including habitat fragmentation, habitat pollution, and the introduction of invasive predators and pathogens (Greggor et al, 2016;Adams et al, 2019;Berger-Tal et al, 2019). Behavioral studies can also help identify the optimal composition of social groups for translocation and help evaluate the success of reintroduction efforts (Berger-Tal et al, 2011).…”

Spatial Overlap and Habitat Selection of Corvid Species in European Cities

“…Other disturbance variables were calculated for each point count. We included light and noise pollution variables while assessing the habitat characteristics of the corvids as these variables have been shown to influence birds’ habitat selection [ 47 , 57 , 58 , 59 ].…”