How genotypic variation results in phenotypic differences is still a challenge for biology. In the field of drug metabolism, the means by which specific cytochrome P4502D6 (CYP2D6) genotypes yield different phenotypes at various levels (molecular, cellular, and organismal) is an important question, as differences in CYP2D6 activity can contribute to adverse drug reactions. Herein, the genotype of CYP2D6 was determined along with the absolute content of CYP2D6 and microsomal protein per gram of liver in human liver microsomes, the molecular, cellular (microsomal, tissue, organ), and organismal phenotype of CYP2D6 determined; the effect of genotype on each phenotype of CYP2D6-mediated dextromethorphan clearance (CL) was delineated, and the overall genotype-phenotype relationship for CYP2D6 was charted. We demonstrate that changes in the cellular and organismal CL phenotypes are markedly greater than changes seen at the molecular level. With individuals carrying the 1661CC polymorphism, for example, the most noticeable change took place in organ CL phenotype (4.17-fold), followed by tissue (3.75-fold), organism (3.69-fold), microsomal (3.09-fold), and molecular (1.66-fold) phenotypes. In addition, the biggest intragenotype individual coefficient of variation in organismal phenotype was observed in the 1661GG individuals, which reached 104.5%, followed by that of 100TT, 100CT, 1661GC, 100CC, and 1661CC polymorphisms (102.7%, 62.4%, 53.5%, 49.7%, and 44.8%, respectively). Our study has allowed us to chart the genotype-phenotype relationship for CYP2D6 from the molecular to the organismal level as well as allowed us to determine intragenotype individual variation in phenotype with each genotype.