Effects of experimenting with physical and virtual manipulatives on students' conceptual understanding in heat and temperature

Abstract

This study aimed to investigate the comparative value of experimenting with physical manipulatives (PM) in a sequential combination with virtual manipulatives (VM), with the use of PM preceding the use of VM, and of experimenting with PM alone, with respect to changes in students' conceptual understanding in the domain of heat and temperature. A pre–post‐comparison study design was used which involved 62 undergraduate students that attended an introductory course in physics. The participants were randomly assigned to one experimental and one control group. Both groups used the same inquiry‐oriented curriculum materials. Participants in the control group used PM to conduct the experiments, whereas, participants in the experimental group used first PM and then VM. VM differed from PM in that it could provide the possibility of faster manipulation, whereas, it retained any other features and interactions of the study's subject domain identical to the PM condition. Conceptual tests were administered to assess students' understanding before, during, and after the study's treatments. Results indicated that experimenting with the combination of PM and VM enhanced students' conceptual understanding more than experimenting with PM alone. The use of VM was identified as the cause of this differentiation. © 2008 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J Res Sci Teach 45: 1021–1035, 2008

Simulaciones computacionales en la enseñanza de la física: una revisión crítica de los últimos años

“…Mediante test conceptual y medición de tiempo de tareas entre otros, llegan a la conclusión de que el laboratorio virtual es más eficiente que el real para el aprendizaje de conceptos en electricidad. En otros estudios, Zacharia (2007), Zacharia et al (2008) y Rodríguz-Llerena y LloveraGonzález (2010) demuestran que una secuencia instruccional con entornos virtuales y reales produce mejores desempeños de los alumnos que entornos exclusivamente reales. …”

Metodologias interativas de ensino na formação de professores de física: um estudo de caso com o método instrução pelos colegas (Peer Instruction)

“…HENDERSON, 2005;HENDERSON;DANCY, 2009). Promover o engajamento dos alunos no processo de aprendizagem tornou-se foco de atenção de vários estudos que mostram que a aprendizagem conceitual é favorecida com métodos de ensino em que o aluno é (co)responsável por sua própria aprendizagem (HELLER et al, 1992;HAKE, 1998;ZACHARIA et al, 2008).…”

Evaluation of Student Learning in Remotely Controlled Instrumental Analyses

“…For many years, the natural assumption for the order of this combination had been to treat the simulation as a pre-lab exercise followed by the real laboratory experience. However, the increased benefit has been seen irrespective of the order of mode (Jaakkola & Nurmi, 2008;Zacharia, Olympiou, & Papaevripidou, 2008) and one group has even reported that the best combination in their teaching laboratory was to do the real experiment first before doing the simulation (Smith & Puntambekar, 2010).…”