“…The authors of [12] conclude in this work that the refractive index surface that governs wavelength and propagation direction dominates the focusing of the radiation which changes from the resonance cone direction (propagation direction in a cold magnetized plasma for which the refractive index approaches infinity), for frequencies that are a factor of 0.75 the electron gyrofrequency to a pencil beam pattern focused along the static magnetic field for lower frequencies that lie within the whistler-mode regime. In [13], Wang and Bell examine the radiation characteristics of an electric dipole at VLF frequencies in a warm magnetoplasma by adding a finite electron temperature effect incorporated through the addition of a scalar pressure term in the cold plasma equations, a commonly used practice at this time [8]. They assert that for frequencies above , propagation characteristics may be significantly altered since the thermally modified whistler mode can propagate at angles beyond the resonance cone, however, for frequencies below , the refractive index surface is basically unmodified while noting radiation efficiencies for the perpendicular antenna greater than at least 10% over the parallel antenna for most cases.…”