Elucidating an Amorphous Form Stabilization Mechanism for Tenapanor Hydrochloride: Crystal Structure Analysis Using X-ray Diffraction, NMR Crystallography, and Molecular Modeling

Abstract

By the combined use of powder and single-crystal X-ray diffraction, solid-state NMR, and molecular modeling, the crystal structures of two systems containing the unusually large tenapanor drug molecule have been determined: the free form, ANHY, and a dihydrochloride salt form, 2HCl. Dynamic nuclear polarization (DNP) assisted solid-state NMR (SSNMR) crystallography investigations were found essential for the final assignment and were used to validate the crystal structure of ANHY. From a structural informatics analysis of ANHY and 2HCl, conformational ring differences in one part of the molecule were observed which influence the relative orientation of a methyl group on a ring nitrogen and thereby impact the crystallizability of the dihydrochloride salt. From quantum chemistry calculations, the dynamics between different ring conformations in tenapanor is predicted to be fast. Addition of HCl to tenapanor results in general in a mixture of protonated ring conformers and hence a statistical mix of diastereoisomers which builds up the amorphous form, a-2HCl. This was qualitatively verified by C CP/MAS NMR investigations of the amorphous form. Thus, to form any significant amount of the crystalline material 2HCl, which originates from the minor (i.e., energetically less stable) ring conformations, one needs to involve nitrogen deprotonation to allow exchange between the minor and major conformations of ANHY in solution. Thus, by controlling the solution pH value to well below the p K of ANHY, the equilibrium between ANHY and 2HCl can be controlled and by this mechanism the crystallization of 2HCl can be avoided and the amorphous form of the dichloride salt can therefore be stabilized.

Chemical shifts in molecular solids by machine learning

“…A revolution in solid-state NMR has occurred with the introduction of accurate methods to calculate chemical shifts 1 – 3 , in particular using plane wave density functional theory (DFT) methods developed for periodic systems based on the projected augmented wave (PAW)/gauge including PAW (GIPAW) approach 4 – 6 . This has enabled very rapid development of chemical shift-based NMR crystallography, which is now widely used to validate structures of molecular solids and identify known polymorphs 7 – 26 , or more recently in combination with crystal structure prediction (CSP) protocols, to determine de novo crystal structures from powders 27 – 32 . Recent studies also suggest that the structural accuracy of chemical shift-based solid-state NMR crystallography is at least comparable with more traditional methods, such as single crystal X-ray diffraction 33 .…”

NMR Crystallography of the Polymorphs of Metergoline

“…This approach was the subject of recent reviews by Ashbrook et al [5] and by Bryce [6]. Additionally, some of its notable applications were most recently discussed by Brown et al [7] and by Emsley et al [8]. Our group successfully employed NMR crystallography in the structural elucidation/refinement of framework materials [9], bioactive compounds [10], and drugs [11][12][13].…”

Periodic DFT Calculations—Review of Applications in the Pharmaceutical Sciences

“…Nowadays various drug delivery systems are developed and in many aspects the research in this field can be supported by theoretical calculations [117,118]. This means from one side, the description of API, which could change its molecular structure, for example, upon uploading into drug carriers, as it takes place in case of ellipticine [119].…”